The Noble Lies of Covid-19
slate.com
slate.com
They just recently updated their guidance on masks for vaccinated people. They say vaccinated people should wear masks indoors again because of the delta variant. But mounting data from the CDC themselves referenced earlier in the very same update shows that the vaccine is just as - maybe even more - effective against the delta variant. And the update does not provide any explanation for why they are reversing previous guidance in light of that data.
Maybe there's something I'm missing. I don't pretend to be an expert. But why should I put any stock in the new guidance after they have fed us so many lies recently?
I believe it is legal, and sometimes best, but most of the time not, for public health officials to say things which could be construed as "lies" (by a bad faith opponent) but, in full analysis, can be seen as ethically the most economic way to achieve a reasonable public health objective.
No scientist should make any public health pronouncements about herd immunity, there just isn't enough data to suggest its a clearly achievable goal. Make reasonable statements that are well-supported by evidence, and when you need to force people to do something for which there isn't full evidence, be transparent that it's not well-supported, but still prudent.
But it's not wrong. Ever read random convos on the internet? Like on social media? People cherry-pick sentences from essays and paragraphs and people have entire conversations divorced from full context. Because people don't read paragraphs, and they refuse to not be in a binary state of Yes or No.
I'm not saying nobody can handle nuanced paragraphs, but I think if your message is always 5+ sentences with any complex logical structure, people will not get it. And bad actors will distort what you say to get people riled up in their favor.
Nearly all modern philosophy is a combination of moral ethics (of which few people can agree on even what morals are right) and consequentialism (make decisions based on what the expected outcome will be) based on wise choices.
Our governement has an attitude to say 'everything is fine' when things are clearly not. As a consequence, no one trusts them on anything. There is a clear cost in not being completely truthfull.
But as a governemental officer, you know people are going to quote you out of context. You know people are enemies just because of your job, and they are going to make the worst possible version of what you say, and they are then going to pile lies upon it until your policy sounds like a comic book end of world plan. Politics is opera, and the loudest voice wins.
Any communication has to be shaped for the specific receiver, and the receiver in this case is nasty. Science gives us reasonable guesses but no absolute clarity, and the vox populi demands a clear course from a clear leader.
If you're pretty sure a white lie or oversimplification will save lives, what is ethically the least worst choice? You'll quickly end up with 50 shades of gray.
Partially correct, I'd argue they also have the goal of minimizing risk to themselves (things like criticism of policy, like what happened in Sweden, or anything that could jeopardize funding or tenure of the leadership). They are not there to make bold decisions, they are there to minimize flak. Also, like all bureaucracies, they have the goal of growing their influence and size.
But even that aside, "maximizing public health" is not the only goal function we have, and when policy decisions are made like that is all we care about, it disenfranchises and discriminates against people who rightfully have competing priorities. This is ine reason why we have a constitution, and there are limits on what government can do. No one entity maximizing it's one goal should be able to trump all other natural rights that we have. Additionally, this is the danger of technocracy overall. The technician is not a politician who negotiates compromise between public good and individual ambitions. He works only to maximize what is in his purview. As such, he's great to listen to for input, but should never be given free reign to dictate peoples behavior.
The question is kind of a wish for certainty about an uncertain thing. Even if 80% are immunized nationally, what if you live in a town where only 60% are? What if your town is 80% immunized but the other 20% all attend the same rally and get covid? Of course there cannot be an answer to such a question.
Between that and the ridiculous anti vax crowd my sympathy is with the public health folks. The fact is that to the best of our knowledge the vaccine works great, and if people are too dumb to get it despite that and endanger others, what choice is left? They can't force you to take it, so we get lies and $1000 cash rewards instead..
It's perfectly valid to believe Fauci lied and also believe the vaccine works. Some people are just never going to get the vax until they personally see friend/family dying from covid, and blaming fauci is simply convenient excuse for it.
Regardless of where your sympathy lies, perhaps it would be good to engage with the substance of the article.
The more lying engaged in by public officials, the more ridiculous the anti-vax crowd will become, precisely because for the majority - lacking the medical expertise to judge vaccine safety - their beliefs are an expression of their trust in the government and experts at large.
If not lying isn't cutting it, you may just have to accept that sometimes policy objectives aren't achievable, given the constraints of human decency. Even when failing to achieve those objectives costs lives.