Anti-Piracy Lawyers Find Cheaper Way To Identify BitTorrent Users
torrentfreak.com
torrentfreak.com
While our justice system is ostensibly set up to allow a small guy to win against a big guy, this next generation of nearly automated litigation against anyone, regardless of a shred of plausible guilt, is a tragedy. The big guy can automate the process of suing any number of small guys and force them to pay up, even if they're innocent.
This is not a legal battle any more. This is blackmail.
Could an ongoing reverse sting a la Barry Cooper [1] be staged to produce a lot of false positives? I imagine few hundred lawsuits against individuals confident of their own innocence could start to curb their profits a little.
The crazy copyright reality just shows that there is a deep, underlying problem with the whole system, which makes it possible for a few to have enough power to simply not allow a widely perceived skewness to be democratically corrected by the populace. We have to obey minority-made laws which a majority of our peers doesnt support. Certain things are simply not allowed to be voted on, and at the moment this is no more apparent than on the issues of drugs and copyright.
The majority of people used to be racist. The majority used to be homophobic. The majority used to be sexist. Three quick examples to outline that public opinion isn't automatically the correct opinion.
Thanks to journalists adopting the term "vox populi" to mean that public opinion is all-important, it's worth remembering the actual quote it is taken from, which translates to:
"And those people should not be listened to who keep saying the voice of the people is the voice of God, since the riotousness of the crowd is always very close to madness.
Besides, the whole idea with anti-discrimination law is that you identify a politically disadvantaged group and ensure they aren't unjustly exploited by a system they have no hope of changing. It's very clear that anti-discrimination laws are designed as an exception to the rule of democracy.
In the case of copyright holders, especially large companies, they are usually the least politically disadvantaged of anyone.
Yeah well you're wrong. There is much more to democracy than the tyranny of the majority.
Sound recordings made before 1972 are under state copyright, not federal.
Also, has anyone been sued for sharing TV shows, or is it just movies?
On the legality, I've heard people day that if you don't upload, it's not illegal. I don't know if that's true. I suspect it's more a case of "if you don't upload, they can't catch you."