How would you design an secure online voting system?
news.ycombinator.com
news.ycombinator.com
On a technological level I think that is pretty sound.
I think however that introduces a bunch of potential social issues in the aftermath:
- If people would get a piece of paper after the vote that shows their random ID and their vote they would have to immediately notify a person working at the voting booth to correct it - If for whatever reason they find out that the official record afterwards shows they vote for someone else, is there gonna be a process to correct it? - If there is, that could open the door for people forging random voting slips in order to swing votes retroactively - If there is a somewhat airtight system that prevents forging it could create a real market for buying votes. If someone wanted to buy a vote nowadays it is pretty hard to verify that the people actually voted for their candidate. Now all the bought voters would need to do is send in or send a picture of their random ID.
You can probably address all of these problems but I'm not sure it will be more economical than paper ballots in the end.
It does introduce one important constraint though, at least compared to the current US system: it's possible to find out how someone voted. I don't know if it's a deal breaker, but it is a significant change. Right now, in the US, once the ballot goes in the box, there's no telling who it belonged to. With the proposed system, a person could be compelled to hand over their secret ID, or it could be bought or stolen from them.
All jokes aside, the old-fashioned paper and pencil ballot is probably the best of all the bad voting methods.
The best is of course a 'show of hands' and a verified physical count of those hands.