To a point, because the manner in which it is delivered also matters a great deal. It's the difference between tearing a person down and motivating them to improve (or to justify their point further as the case may be). Consider the following extreme scenarios:
In case A an argument is based on decidedly wrong reasoning or false data, but it's delivered in an accessible and friendly way that encourages further discussion.
Case B is a statement that is factually 100% correct and verifiable but it's brought across in a manner designed to be as abrasive as possible and to show off the superiority of the participant.
Considering those two extremes, I believe argument A is more constructive to the overall process because it enabled a productive discussion to continue (if only to show why the argument is mistaken). In contrast, B, not so much. Of course, in reality it gets way more complex than this. Not only is there a spectrum between factual correctness and incorrectness, between being approachable and being obnoxious. The crux is often the "based on reality" part, because we also tend to disagree about the pertinence of certain facts to a given discussion. But stating a factually true observation in a context where this observation is not relevant to the issue is often extremely disruptive.
To employ an extreme example: person 1 says "X + Y equals 5" to which person 2 counters "but X is a negative number". Statement 2, while it may well be based on reality, is not constructive criticism - it's misleading and distracting, and it makes person 1 look bad for no reason. In fact, I just had such an interaction on HN a few hours ago. So I believe intentions (and the perceptions thereof) make all the difference when it comes to an exchange being constructive.