Hacker News Reader

The problem with doing this in Python is that there is no typing or interfaces to help you. Basing it purely on naming of arguments breaks the assumption that argument names are local to the function/method. I find this extremely confusing to reason about, let alone the possible unwanted side effects if some developer isn’t aware that a name is magical. It’s also very non Pythonic for good reasons.

View on HN

I feel the same way (and mostly use unittest instead) but maybe this technique makes sense as long as its use is limited to test functions?

Test functions are never called explicitly and would otherwise (like unittest TestCase methods) never have any arguments, so in this context maybe it's clear that any arguments they do have must be magical.

It can actually play really well with Python's optional typing. I should add that to the implementation in Datasette!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com