Playing devil's advocate here a little: The whole machine is very counter-intuitive, and I can see how I myself may disbelieve it if not for the irrefutable demonstration(s)[0].
Playing devil's advocate here a little: The whole machine is very counter-intuitive, and I can see how I myself may disbelieve it if not for the irrefutable demonstration(s)[0].
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCsgoLc_fzI&t=812s
This is exactly what the blackbird does, only with a propeller pushing air in place of the big wheel, and it's a much clearer and simpler demonstration of the same idea, which you can trivially verify.
EDIT: As an aside, I would also add that the original video did a poor job at explaining, and the demo had clear flaws which were the points the physics professor was making. More specifically, his 2 main points were
1. It's possible that when the picture of the flag was taken, the wind was slower than the car, but the car was still moving faster due to momentum
2. It's possible that the wind speed up at the propeller level is different from the ground level where the flag was
Those were both very valid criticisms, even though they didn't actually matter in the grander scheme of things.
Energy is 1/2mv^2, and momentum (related to force) is mv. Anytime you have different speeds, you can arbitrage.
If I am pushing against still air, I can generate nearly-infinite force for arbitrarily little energy.
That's why you use wings instead of pointing jet engines downwards. You push a lot of air by a little bit (lots of mv, not a lot of 1/2mv^2, since v is small).
If I am going an epsilon faster than the wind, with very little energy, I can push hard on the air.
But it's not all too complicated. With pencil and paper, I could explain to a high school student. If you've done college level mechanics, that's on me, or on the medium.
Perhaps I need to make a video explaining this clearly, since people are running in circles around this and it's just not very hard.
The definitions of kinetic energy and momentum and some basic differentiation, that should all be thoroughly covered.
It sorta shows that it's possible, but it doesn't really show why it works in this case.
1. Air isn't solid.
2. There aren't two rollers.
The analogy is a little bit distant.
I just need to find time to make mine more eloquent.
For example, "some efficiency loss" is complex and a little bit inaccurate. It's not just efficiency loss:
- In the mechanical analogy, I can extract infinite power from a board moving at a given speed. There is no upper bound on the force the board can apply to me.
- In the case of a fan, there is an upper bound on the power which can be extracted given a specific air speed, even given perfect efficiency.
Now, it's possible to correctly argue that as the fan size increases, I can make a closer and closer to this analogue. However:
- Once you start making arguments like that, cognitive load increases, and beginners start to drop off. You need to keep more and more steps in your head.
- And more often than not, an imprecise argument simply reinforces or introduces some misconception, rather than giving an honest understanding.
I think a force*distance argument (which is probably a clearer way of stating the argument I was making above) has the virtues of:
1. Being 100% precise
2. Being compact enough someone who understands force, power, and energy can keep the whole argument in their head