How does that follow? It certainly seems that spending $9K/year or less compared to coughing up 3 to 10 times that to hire proves that attention to retention is nowhere near that given to hiring.
How does that follow? It certainly seems that spending $9K/year or less compared to coughing up 3 to 10 times that to hire proves that attention to retention is nowhere near that given to hiring.
Companies are either making a near universal error that has been well publicized at this point or the number is wrong and hiring is nowhere near that expensive.
Amazon is a very data driven company. But they have no problem churning through people like crazy. They are a company with hire to fire, so if hiring an SDE cost $50,000, they are letting managers spend 50K to fiddle with attrition stats.
Amazon delays equity a lot, so it may look financially sensible to churn through people.
Beyond that though, companies make plenty of universal errors. Can you think of any other errors the -average- company makes, that may cost them money?
I can see equity being a reason for Amazon, but it is hardly just equity granting companies that are this way.
But retention also isn't an easy metric to solve for. It's not "just do X and watch that number improve". The closest thing companies do is throw money at people, but that only works if you're so far higher than the rest of the market that people are looking at a massive paycut if they go somewhere else, and that still is only one data point affecting those averages. Certainly, no company that I left could have kept me by throwing $9k more at me; I made more than that with every company change I made, let alone what actually caused me to start looking in the first place.
Retention and engagement are hard, complicated problems. The mindset that employees are interchangeable cogs with no real needs of their own—particularly psychological needs that have anything to do with the workplace—is still a very strong one in every sector of the American workplace. Even for those companies where management, as a whole, does genuinely understand that it benefits everyone to have engaged employees, if you ask 10 people "how do you keep employees engaged?" you'll get 12 different answers.
We're still just a few steps away from tenant farmers, sweatshops, and company towns. The fact that there's research that shows spending on retention is massively more effective than spending on hiring will take generations more to actually catch on amongst the American executive class...unless we can manage to pull together a serious union renaissance and demand the better conditions that will actually help everyone.
1) Just like in Sales, on average it is cheaper _and_ marginally more profitable to retain an employee than to recruit a new one. This includes cost to recruit, interview, onboard, etc.
2) The exceptions here that throw off the average are those companies with strong inbound hiring pipelines (ex: Amazon will never have a shortage of applicants) that reduce the costs of recruiting + interviewing, and retaining high performers (e.g.: the cost of losing an upper-decile performer is much more significant.)
I imagine that if there was a law that said companies could write off half or more what they spend on employee retention and development, you'd see Amazon and others put a lot more money that direction.