Is Siberia a useful counterfactual, where the typical criticisms are more along the lines of too much logging (deforestation) and not fighting fires in the wilderness?
Or are these environments just too different?
Is Siberia a useful counterfactual, where the typical criticisms are more along the lines of too much logging (deforestation) and not fighting fires in the wilderness?
Or are these environments just too different?
At one point, more than a third of the USSR's electricity (if not power) came from peat fueled generators so we're talking millions of square miles of almost completely inaccessible forest floor covered with a meters thick layer of material that is literally a precursor to coal deposits and dirtier to boot. The only feasible way of mitigating these fires (burning the peat for power) accelerates the very environmental effects causing them!
By comparison, California's ecology doesn't support peat formation and the PNW's access to the coast dampens the extreme weather that causes such extreme buildup (though it's becoming more and more of a problem). However, as you get deeper inland into Canada, Idaho, and Montana, the more the land starts to resemble Siberia so it's only a matter of time before we get similar wildfires.
I'm strongly sympathetic to the argument that the US and Canada have mismanaged their forests in a way that increases fire risk. However it's also clear that climate itself is playing a major role, with forsts burning earlier and later in the year, hotter, and more frequently, than in the past, as well as in places where forest-management practices really don't much come into play. The fact that wildfire prevalence is increasing worldwide, including where total fire suppression has NOT been practiced seems to be the fatal blow to forest mismanagement as a principle cause.
Again, I don't at all doubt it contributes. But the global trends suggest something more at hand.
________________________________
Notes:
1. See e.g., https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28083657
That means natural fires will be about three times as far away from firefighters in Siberia. Siberia likely also has fewer roads/km², making it even harder for on the ground firefighters to reach fires.
Also, warmer summers have increased the number of thunderstorms in the Arctic. https://wtop.com/weather-news/2021/03/as-the-arctic-warms-li...:
“Arctic lightning has tripled in just the last decade […] In the Arctic Circle there was an even greater increase in lightning strikes in the Eastern Hemisphere, specifically over Siberia“
(I think I’m not misquoting this by cutting out text, but corrections welcome)
Even though that text plays it down, I think that seems a likely explanation for an increase in forest fires.
This fire danger page from the park service seems helpful.
the most important factor in public perception of those events - domestic politics (and thus resulting media propaganda spin in particular) - are very different.
The main real factor is the same in both cases though - it is climate change, and whether too much or too little of logging, whether active fire suppression is practiced or not is just a noise compare to the ground-shifting effects of the climate change.
In either case giving current climate there should be different type forest than what is there now - the forest just hasn't been able to adjust naturally that fast. Thus the various ways of catastrophic adjustment including by fires and die-offs.