Earthships as imagined by Michael Reynolds are super specific to New Mexico. The design works well there, but if you try those techniques in basically any other part of the country, you are gonna have a bad time.
I think the biggest takeaway from the philosophy is "actually think about design and construction based on the location, rather than what is common/easy." Stick-in-place construction is widely common in USA, even when that design is an antipattern in a climate (such as the southwest).
See: why the standard Earthship (tm) (yes it's a trademark, anything else is just Sparkling Sustainable Architecture) designs are a bad choice for cold climates.
https://www.ecohome.net/guides/1161/do-earthships-work-in-co...
tl;dr - they are a design stuck in the 70's in NM. Eco architecture has advanced significantly since then.