From the article:
We also found that bug-fixing commits by authors tended to be larger in size and scope, and address multiple issues, whereas bug-fixing commits by other developers tended to be smaller and more focused on the bug itself.
This makes sense. If I'm fixing a bug in code I'm not super sure about, I want the change to be as focused as possible because even if it looks like it should be made into a bigger change, I don't know what the knock-on effects will be. There's also a matter of not being sure if the desire to rewrite a large chunk just comes down to personal preference.
Yeah, in my case at least "what the hell were they thinking" comes down not to them having solved the problem incorrectly, but a difference in the shapes of our minds.