So not recognising the fine is disingenuous hypocritical crock and far from trustworthy reporting. Guardian, do better.
So not recognising the fine is disingenuous hypocritical crock and far from trustworthy reporting. Guardian, do better.
Cambridge analytica deceived people to steal and sell data, and to invisibly manipulate them.
These NYU researchers are scientists, whose entire work is only valuable if put into the open, and who are boud do law and supervised by many checks and balances - soft and hard ones.
It must be possible to study platforms, and for people to volunteer their data with informed consent to science. Otherwise the entire mechanism of "self-observation" of society falls apart.
So yes, it would be good to mention the caveat that Facebook does need to protect users. But no, that's almost entirely not the issue here.
From the article: > Facebook claimed that we were violating its terms of service, that we were compromising user privacy, and that it had no choice but to shut us down because of an agreement it has with the Federal Trade Commission. All of these claims are wrong. Ad Observer collects information only about advertisers, not about our volunteers or their friends, and the FTC has stated that our research does not violate its consent decree with Facebook.
If these NYU researchers have in fact created an identical system with identical strategies and goals, and are lying blatantly in the Guardian, that should be big news!
I’m somewhat skeptical about the equivalence here.
As an aside, I don't use Facebook at all, and wouldn't trust them with my dog's name either.