Asteroid Bennu now has a greater chance of hitting Earth through 2300
edition.cnn.com
edition.cnn.com
Also, with the trajectory we are on regarding climate change, there might not be the resources needed or a humanity capable to carry on this task of destroying/diverting the asteroid in 2300.
This is a massive understatement. If the claims of climate activists are to be believed, the only way to beat climate change is to have the entire industrialized world return to a pre-industrialized state[0]. Since not everyone will want to adopt the living standards of Zambia[0], effecting such a change also would inevitably involve killing anyone who refused. Every American would need to cut their energy usage by 90%[0] or up against the wall! This is about a lot more than the politicians and their donors, this is about reversing the clock on progress two hundred years
0 https://reason.com/2021/07/02/to-stop-climate-change-america...
Carbon taxes are the best economic solution, and UBIs are extremely popular
If you look at one proposal, HR.2307 in the US, it says that it will introduce a $20/ton of CO2 price, which will step up by $10 per ton every year. This means that 1 gallon of gas would have an additional tax of $0.18, stepping up by $0.09 every year. Not too terrible, but any rise in the price of gas is met with hostility in the US just because many people are reliant on cars as their only source of transportation.
If the bill does attract enough support and goes to the floor, it will attract media attention. And since most media attention focuses on the most tangible immediate implications for most adults, most reporting will center on the rise of gasoline prices. This will trigger strong political opposition, in unison from huge diverse ranges of the population, regardless of how much money they would get from a redistribution of the money.
I'd support a tax like this if there were greener options with similar or cheaper cost to use for the riders (e.g. rail, busses). Unfortunately, the infrastructure just isn't there yet for a vast majority of the US.
Carbon pricing would fall disproportionately on the poor, as most changes to society do. But then again, the effects of climate change would also fall disproportionately on the poor. What’s going to be worse?
Entirely back of the napkin of course, other costs will skew the numbers. But so long as we have both the tax and the redistribution in place it should balance year over year.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Green_New_Deal&mo...
https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2020/06/23/two-thirds-of...
Calculating other Countries carbon emmissions is going to be a very difficult problem. There will be some intense negotiations between treaty members to determine suitable methodologies.
Unfortunately, the top 5 oil producing companies are based in Saudi Arabia, Russia, Kuwait, Iran, and China respectively. It's going to be a challenge to persuade them all to stop digging.
What is desperately needed is carbon reduction, not financial maneuvers.
Let's say a billionaire had enough money to build a vanity project rocket so they could go to the stratosphere just for kicks. I know, I know... Who the fuck would do such a thing. But if...
What if a huge corporation wants to buy up millions of acres of rainforest to flatten it and grow cash crops or worse, farm cattle? Would the carbon tax put them off? Or would it be like those paltry fines that they pay after they "woops" and spill a million gallons of oil?
I don't think there should be carbon tax. I think there should be a carbon budget per person, and a similar arrangement for corporations. It doesn't matter how much money you have, if you take 3 helicopter rides you better pay for a clement winter.
But also, China having done so, the West will undergo a horrendous sense of FOMO, and dig itself out of its own ditch to catch up.
Without a competitor, western nations are just crabs in the crab pot, pulling each other deeper into the increasingly boiling water IMO.
However, even with that commitment, China is bringing more fossil fuel energy online, instead of taking it offline [1].
What information do you have that indicates China will pursue faster climate change mitigation?
[1] https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/china-...
They continue to have a lower per capita footprint than the West. And I could be wrong but it would be consistent with everything else I've seen them do in the past decade - I spent part of the year over there every year for the past decade until the pandemic and that's just my take. YMMV.
*https://spectrum.ieee.org/china-closing-in-on-thorium-nuclea...
They have moved hundreds of millions from the latter to the former. They have hundreds of millions left to go and are making excellent progress.
Two totally different threat levels.