It what way?
It what way?
Misinformation is subjective. There is nobody we can trust to be the arbiter of what is misinformation and what isn’t.
Also the first attempts have failed terribly.
However, I don’t trust any broad society wide effort to censor anything. Even if it works well now and the deceiving evil people of today are muted it WILL bite us down the road when evil people use the precedent and mechanism to silence truth.
I would rather we spend our time educating our people to be rigorous thinkers vs controlling what they are exposed to.
You believe climate change is real. I don't. It's 50/50, so nothing happens on a policy level and we all slowly die.
See the problem?
> I would rather we spend our time educating our people to be rigorous thinkers vs controlling what they are exposed to.
Por que no los dos?
I dont think we should control information just because someone doesnt like it.
The stakes are too high (democracy, climate change, public health) to allow purposeful lies to cloud our ability to actually address these problems. These are weaponized lies, not benign mistakes.
Which is the definition of disinfo.
What if the “authorities” are wrong? Is it disinfo to say so? For example: Is suspecting a lab leak as the cause of Covid disinfo, misinfo, wrong or right? (We dont know yet a lot of sites flag it as misinfo) same for the CDCs flip flopping on masks. Would predicting a catastrophic collapse of Afghanistan 2 weeks ago been misinfo?
Obviously all of these are nuanced and thats the point. A binary classification is rarely appropriate but highly tempting.
Being wrong on purpose, to degrade the conversation itself. Gaslighting, whataboutism, etc. These are techniques used on purpose to destroy a conversation, and it's not simply about being "wrong".
> What if the “authorities” are wrong? Is it disinfo to say so?
No.
> Is suspecting a lab leak as the cause of Covid disinfo, misinfo, wrong or right?
Good example. Early theories were not about a natural virus, studied at Wuhan, that escaped. They were about an engineered bioweapon released on purpose. The latter theory was banned (and continues to be). If there was a measured, logical case for a leak as opposed to a frenzied conspiracy theory, I didn't see it.
However, if it is false (most likely) then banning it puts in a dark place away from sunlight where it can grow and mutate and spread. Streisand effect comes into effect here.
Respectfully it sounds like you already bought into the idea that "the experts" (if that can be referred to as a monolith, which I disagree it can) are usually wrong. Btw, no one got Afghanistan "wrong". Most knew the country would fall, no one knew how fast. That's a good example of how, when people claim "the experts got it wrong", they don't understand what said "experts" were actually predicting.