Musk's 'AI Day' confronts tough questions about Tesla's technology
reuters.com
reuters.com
This was a lie. It wasn't a mistake, or a "complicated and contradictory view". It was something that was clearly false, said by someone in the best possible position to know that it was false.
Journalism that tries to soften that is just indirect soft-touch PR. Despite the article mentioning multiple times that Tesla has "walked back" similar claims - something that happens so frequently that it can't really be omitted - the overall tone of the article is still far too accepting of Tesla's overall narrative.
Not trying to defend Musk here, just pointing out the philosophical and legal challenges of preventing stuff like this in the future. I don't really have any good answers - maybe we should allow law enforcement to search emails and other communications to look for evidence of explicit and intentional deceit in high profile cases like this.
Either he lied deliberately, or he deliberately chose to ignore all relevant information to his work and field as a whole and still make the claim (even more dishonest, and would make many of his other, seemingly innocuous claims also lies). There's no other option that holds together.
This was not an understandable mistake or oversight. It's not something he could have genuinely believed. It's a wild, wild claim that is obviously nonsense to anyone with even a little knowledge of this field, similar to his claim about language becoming obsolete [1].
As much as we know anything at all, we know that Elon Musk deliberately made this claim in the knowledge that it was false.
[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/ne...