Google is gagging user advocates
infotrope.net
infotrope.net
> @Skud: ok, unless someone tells me otherwise, it looks like google employees who don’t support the names policy have been gagged. #nymwars
> @Skud: @lizthegrey this is your chance to tell me i’m wrong, btw.
Somebody not responding to your tweet is hardly proof employees are being gagged. Here's one idea: maybe Liz doesn't want to be the center of attention on this anymore.
>On July 25th (four days ago) she stopped posting on the subject altogether. Looking at her stream, though, I see that she did post, without any comment, a link to a Wikipedia article talking about gag orders.
Further, the poster says liz is a friend, so it seems likely they'd get some response to a direct question if she wasn't gagged.
Of course, if you're suggesting that she simply got burnt out, that's a possibility. I could understand decreasing the number of essays written on the subject, but responding to a tweet seems like something that she'd do, given her previous crusade.
How much will it take to make people quit(quitquit)?
I mean we really have no idea, but it seems far far more likely something like that occurred than Google sending a formal C&D to one of it's own employees.
Are you sure it's not just a service that some people won't want to use, because of this design decision? Or is it fundamentally evil to offer a web service some people might not want to use?
I have no argument whatsoever that services should not exist that not only allow pseudonyms but where pseudonyms are embraced and expected. I love many of these services, and would defend their right to exist to no end.
But I do not even remotely understand what seems to be a prevailing argument here that there must not exist any service based on real names.
All of the argument in favor of pseudonym is really an argument in favor of those types of services existing -- which they do, in spades. Millions of them. No one is, or has, killed anonymous or pseudonymous interaction on the web. No one is, or has, hindered the ability of a person seeking such cover from the ability to publish anything on the web and to be found.
Its an additional service offering, its not a subtraction of what already exists (rampant, multitudinous options for anonymous and pseudonymous posting which can and are being used by folks seeking avenues for anonymous and pseudonymous posting and sharing and community building).
Also, right now, you're right, this doesn't matter. You can just ignore their dumb little toy and go on with life. Trouble is, future services are planned to be integrated. That means you either suck it up and create a profile (thus running into the Real Name fiasco) or opt out of anything which needs one.
Using one thing to force people to do another thing. Where have we seen this before?
If you're inside the company and you care about this stuff, you're probably freaking out because it reflects on you, too.
From a business perspective outside of the company, it's brilliant. It means there will be a lot of people looking for alternative ways to do things where they were previously relying on the big G since it was good enough. I guess I should just shut up and let them keep digging that hole. It'll mean more business for the rest of us.
You and I have dramatically different definitions of evil. Basically you are saying that yes, launching a service that some people, in your eyes (or in someone's) will not like, is evil. Pretty narrow little circle of goodness you've left yourself with, one that likely encompasses nothing.
"Using one thing to force people to do another thing. Where have we seen this before?"
Except there exists no force.
"From a business perspective outside of the company, it's brilliant. It means there will be a lot of people looking for alternative ways to do things where they were previously relying on the big G since it was good enough. I guess I should just shut up and let them keep digging that hole. It'll mean more business for the rest of us."
That is why anonymous and pseudonymous activity will exist and thrive as it always has, because there is a market for it.
Funnily enough that also roughly describes the effect Facebook is having on the broader web, in many ways. Hundreds of millions of people prefer the safe confines of Facebook to the broader web. They have found it to be the better alternative way to do things. Apparently, there is a very strong consumer demand for that market, as well. Real names is not a hindrance to Facebooks success with that specific market, it is central to it. Facebook is not a small community.
What your argument boils down to -- is that Google is both stupid and evil for wanting to serve both markets, to have two types of services. EVIL, mind you.
It just seems an odd criticism that is far over-the-top, relative to the actual situation of offering a web service to compete for a market that is obviously huge, in demand, and dramatically underserved (choice of 1 real name social network, basically, vs in essense hundreds of thousands of anonymous networks).
Citizen: The government is dissecting aliens!
Government: Uh, no we're not.
Citizen: Further proof that you are!
This sounds a lot like that.
As for the this 'gag' stuff she offers no proof and seems like she is just conveniently picking narrative to complement her disapproval.
Just let it go already.
Though I don't think it's an issue that deserves the sort of day-after-day-after-day-after-day-after-day-after-day nonstop coverage it's getting. It's a minor-ish problem some people have with a new product or service, though, and for some reason the tech press loves to latch onto those and make them into OMG ONLY THE BIGGEST PROBLEM EVAR (see: "antennagate").
2. The gag stuff sounds pretty well confirmed by Skud's contacts at Google, a company she was until very recently employed at and knows a lot more about the internal machinations of. Where do you work, exactly? (And by the way, why are you posting under a pseudonym?)
2. Still not a proof. And she could be interpreting other instructions as forcing a 'gag'.
And me using a pseudonym here has nothing to do with anything
Also having a misleading headline doesn't help validate the content of the post.
As for "proof", either you haven't read Skud's entire post, or you're just calling her a liar. Oddly enough, I trust her up-front statements more than your vague intimations.
You using a pseudonym has a lot to do with the present issue. The entire issue revolves around pseudonyms. You apparently have no objection to forcing people not to use pseudonyms, but use one yourself. I think that's needs to be explored if you're to have any credibility in a debate about Google's policy on pseudonyms.
You still haven't said where you work.
The headline isn't at all misleading. It is slightly vague, but the vagueness is resolved simply by clicking the link. Vague headlines are nothing new.
I'm saying that she is on a crusade and she might be interpreting things from that prospective.
I use pseudonyms where they are allowed and don't go on a crusade when they aren't.
I don't work for Google if that is what you're asking.
Yes, that is the concept behind link-baiting.
I'm not using Google+ because of their policy and I don't describe myself as an "activist".