I'd laugh if the shareholders fired the CEO over a boneheaded move like that, since (at least in my mind) it would seem replacing 1500 people is not a good use of the organization's time and energy and such an exodus was self inflicted
I'd laugh if the shareholders fired the CEO over a boneheaded move like that, since (at least in my mind) it would seem replacing 1500 people is not a good use of the organization's time and energy and such an exodus was self inflicted
It wasn't just quitting. They were offered $1000 in severance. Only a third of the workers took the offer.
It seems like they're trying to get consistency from fewer staff that are more focused on the job. And less costly to employ. That, or eventually replace them with algorithmic picking.
The company missed revenue targets, lost multiple senior staff, and the new CEO is from Bain capital. They're doing this on purpose.
That explains the introduction of black-box management-solely-via-P&L. If any position could be automated away, one would think that that sort of CEO could...
I can't help but imagine that Neutral Planet from Futurama would be the end result of that, constant model fit of the median until the market doesn't even cater to the outliers, and everyone wears the same grey jumpsuit.
Is it just the cost of scheduling these workers?
This seems like an inflection point for the company where their software is starting to be more useful than their employees. It's the equivalent of McDonald's replacing counter people with kiosks.
Shopping algorithms seem really good at finding very similar items in my experience. That's great when I'm shopping for a cheap router, or some other commodity. When shopping for something like clothing, you frequently want VERY dissimilar items to compare, OR you want complementary, but differently categorized items.
Get rid of the human touch at your own peril. Especially when your business model is built on taste.
Looking at stitch fix pricing it is not cheap. It looks a lot like you would expect somewhere like Nordstrom's to price. It's worth noting that Nordstrom's is more than happy to have an employee act as a personal stylist at no cost.
Most people, almost by definition, have rather ordinary tastes. They will want to imagine that it's slightly better than average, but not outrageous.
I don't know much about fashion, but I see it a lot in food marketing. Restaurants differentiate themselves on trendy but safe choices. It works down from the high end: Gordon Ramsey splashes something with truffle oil, and a few years later you can get New Burger King Truffle Fries. A lot of "mom & pop" restaurants are just heating up things off of Sysco trucks.
I don't mean that to sound snobbish. People should enjoy whatever they like. I'm slightly turned off when it's marketed as being really innovative while smaller, more interesting things languish, but that's just the market at work.
As it applies here, I suspect that most people really could be very happy with algorithmically applied clothing. A truly personal stylist would be much more expensive and outside of most people's comfort zones anyway -- unless they did basically the same thing as the algorithm.
What Stitch Fix can offer is the illusion that you're being truly stylish without any of the risks. Which is a fine thing, as far as I'm concerned, if it makes them happy. That excludes a market which really does want a truly personal, human stylist, but I suspect that market isn't nearly as large, and even smaller if you ask them to pay what hours of attention would really cost.
If it's nothing more than "You mentioned that you liked the coat that [celebrity] wore, and this was a similar sort of look but in [color] you said you liked", that could potentially give people a really positive experience. Even if many people are wearing the same coat because the algorithm recommends it.
This is exactly the Stitch Fix approach.