EJ don't have to be a liar. Simply Interpreting the event differently and taking that to court could be enough.
How? If I'm not mistaken the terms clearly say the company is not responsible in these kind of situations.
The classic example is those signs in parking lots saying "we accept no liability for damage to your car". Well in an unmodified common law jurisdiction, it's a bailee-bailor relationship and they are on the hook for the damage.
Contracts are not like computer programs. They can and do include deliberate bullshit included purely for strategic bluffing purposes.
Of course, IANAL, TINLA.
I don't care either way, the main point is that we don't have enough information to make any useful conclusions.
It would be nice to at least admit that.
You've just decided that the source's word is no good when nothing she's said has been disputed by any party. If you ignore her because you don't like what she has to say, then yeah, you wouldn't have "enough information to make any useful conclusions."
You have no way of knowing what is going on. Feel free to speculate just don't wrap it into a vail of certainty when it's clearly not.
She don't have to lie for your interpretation of the whole matter to be wrong.
If you have ever dealt with angry customers or mis treated customers you would know what I mean. Things a rarely as crystal clear as they seem.