My dad has survived three bouts with different forms of cancer - he's healthy and could be around for a long time. Please don't let your pride put his life in danger.
My dad has survived three bouts with different forms of cancer - he's healthy and could be around for a long time. Please don't let your pride put his life in danger.
For instance, this[1] study suggests that the risk of Myocarditis from COVID in young men is six times higher from an infection than from a vaccination. If we assume a gratuitous infection risk of 100%, this may sound like a reasonable benefit. If we however consider that actual COVID infections may be undercounted by a factor of 10[2], the benefit turns negative.
[1] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.07.23.21260998v...
[2] https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
Even if the vaccine increased the risk (it doesn’t), the risk of COVID-19 is orders of magnitude higher than the risk of the Myocarditis heart condition.
There have been, from the total of 12,910,312 18-24 year-old people vaccinated, [2] about 229 cases of this rare heart disease (and, in almost all cases, the person was discharged from the hospital the same day with a clean bill of health) That means the vaccine has under a 0.002% chance of causing a very rare but not fatal heart condition. [3]
COVID-19, on the other hand, has an overall 1.66% chance of killing someone (38,043,754 cases, 629,644 deaths). [4]
I would rather take a 0.002% non-fatal risk than a 1.66% fatal risk.
Sources:
[1] i.e. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.07.23.21260998v... “Young males infected with the virus are up 6 times more likely to develop myocarditis as those who have received the vaccine.”
[2] https://usafacts.org/visualizations/covid-vaccine-tracker-st...
[3] https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/evidence-grows-st...
[4] https://samiam.org/COVID-19/ derived from https://github.com/nytimes/covid-19-data/
An honest, apples to apples statistical comparison here would compare 18-24 year old death rates to 18-24 year old heart problems risk, not lumping all deaths regardless of age together.
> I would rather take a 0.002% non-fatal risk than a 1.66% fatal risk.
Statistical problems aside, I’m happy if you take a vaccine or boosters that you feel is necessary for your health.
I think all the unvaccinated want is the same absolute right to decide the same for themselves.
Additionally, I am extremely concerned that their irresponsible actions are going to let Covid-19 mutate enough that it can work out a variant that the vaccine will be ineffective against.
The main COVID-19 mutations of concern right now are happening in other countries where the vaccine is not widely available yet. The Delta variant was first seen in India, the Beta variant was first seen in South Africa, and the Gamma variant was first seen in Brazil.
We need to make sure the entire world is vaccinated to stop these mutations from coming out of the woodwork.
(See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variants_of_SARS-CoV-2 for sources and discussion)
The fact that we currently see mutations coming out populations that aren't vaccinated is a number's game. Most of the world population is not vaccinated. Vaccinating the last 30% in developed nations will not change that.
If the vaccines dull the symptoms to the point that vaccinated people don't readily know that they're sick, then vaccinated people aren't going to be staying home when they're carriers.
In contrast, it seems far likelier that unvaccinated people will feel ill and stay home.
A large proportion of unvaccinated persons is strongly correlated with higher case rates.
Did you really observe that? There's many highly vaccinated countries that have seen spikes with extremely high r-values.
However, I am willing to come up with more suitable figures.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1191568/reported-deaths-... says there have been 2,630 deaths from COVID-19 for 18-29 year olds (never mind the suffering COVID-19 causes people in this age range). Something that causes 2,630 deaths is more risky than something causing 229 non-fatal hospital visits.
> I think all the unvaccinated want is the same absolute right to decide the same for themselves.
In terms of freedom of choice, I think we would be a lot better off just giving our extra vaccines to Mexico until that have a higher vaccination rate; Mexico has, last time I looked, a 25% vaccination rate compared to the 50% vaccination rate in the US. Once Latin America is well vaccinated, we can circle back to the vaccine hesitant here in the US.
There was recently a rather morbid conversation on Reddit speculating about how much vaccine hesitancy might help Democrats in future elections: https://old.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/pbeigk/desantiss_... Not to mention this graph: https://i.redd.it/4o4i7arucpj71.png (Discussion: https://old.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/pbzaeg/oc_... )
So, guess what, those “newspaper articles and statistics websites” have the same general numbers as more official sources like the FDA; indeed, the CDC’s own numbers are higher than the number I used for COVID-19 deaths among young adults. (And, oh, if you think the CDC’s figures are faulty, I have nothing more to say to you; you’re not looking too good after insinuating that https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.07.23.21260998 didn’t attempt to measure total COVID-19 infections, when, in fact, a cursory reading of the paper shows they did)
With something as fast moving as COVID-19, the press often times gets accurate figures before they’re formally published.
If you want to convince me the numbers I used are wrong, please give me up to date numbers from reliable sources which contradict my figures. Not estimates from a paper written a few months ago.
Finally, I need to flat out ask you: Have you gotten the COVID-19 vaccine yet? I got mine months ago. I will not respond to you again until I know your vaccination status.
And I, personally, refuse to grant them that courtesy. If you want to smoke twelve packs a day (while living in a country with no healthcare) then feel free buddy - but not getting vaccinated effects everyone - including those who choose to help move us past this pandemic by getting vaccinated.
This isn't a question of individual rights vs. the authoritarianism in the same way that wanting to be a thief isn't an individual decision. You can't be a thief without stealing from other people so we've agreed as a society to make it illegal - the same goes for vaccination. The US is currently tip-toeing on a knifes edge trying to avoid an open revolt of stupid people while also trying to make the vaccine mandatory - that open revolt would result in a severe jump in case count... but the government is facing facts that simply coddling people won't make the pandemic go away.
[1] https://www.fda.gov/media/151733/download (Page 24)
Inalienable human rights are not a courtesy for you to grant.
And for what it's worth, I'm not concerned with legality: lawyers can and will legally justify anything they want to. I'm 100% sure that your claim about the law is correct. I'm sure that various inhuman authoritarian laws are going to be tried in America over Covid-19 and legally upheld. Politicians, businesses trying to make big bucks, and moral busybodies will never let a good crisis go to waste.
I'm concerned about morality. It is utterly reprehensible to force a human to inject something into his body against his will. No judge, law, legislature, vote, or disease changes that fact.
I can't disagree that compelled vaccination may be personally immoral for you - but I don't think it's in any way viewed as unethical. It is accepted at a societal level even if some individuals will reject it - and, due to the widespread effects of this pandemic, I think the society we're contemplating to derive ethics here is the global one.
What you calculated is the case fatality rate (CFR), but the infection fatality rate (IFR) is a better representation of risk from SARS-COV-2 infection.
The global average IFR is recently estimated to be ~0.15% [1], which is extremely skewed by age.
All estimates of age stratified IFR show a gradient that decreases by orders of magnitude with age - we're talking IFRs below 0.003% for healthy young adults and children [2][3].
Furthermore, there is substantial evidence that the CFRs & IFRs are significant overestimates [5]. This completely changes the risk-reward tradeoff for many people.
I am not advocating against vaccination (it is a powerful tool that saves lives) - just spreading knowledge and illustrating the fact that everyone has a different risk-reward profile based on their age and health, and should make personal health decisions accordingly.
[1] Reconciling estimates of global spread and infection fatality rates of COVID- 19: An overview of systematic evaluations https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/eci.13...
[2] Infection fatality rate of COVID-19 inferred from seroprevalence data https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7947934/
[3] COVID-19 antibody seroprevalence in Santa Clara County, California https://academic.oup.com/ije/article/50/2/410/6146069
[4] Model-informed COVID-19 vaccine prioritization strategies by age and serostatus https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/371/6532/916.full...
[5] Evaluating the massive underreporting and undertesting of COVID-19 cases in multiple global epicenters https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S253104372...
There have been 2,630 deaths from COVID-19 for 18-29 year olds (never mind the suffering COVID-19 causes people in this age range) in the US. Something that causes 2,630 deaths is more risky than something causing 229 non-fatal hospital visits (the heart condition which has gotten far too much attention).
In terms of IFR vs. case fatality rate, the most comprehensive metastudy you cite, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/eci.13... estimates that we only have 1 case per 10 infections (the Lau 2021 paper which claims we only have 1 case per 50-100 infections is obviously not true in the United States, since the cumulative COVID-19 case count is over 10% of the US population; don’t put too much faith in and do not cherry pick an individual study). Assuming an IFR 10x the CFR, we have a 0.16% IFR rate, which is still orders of magnitude larger than the 0.002% rate we are seeing with people who get that non-fatal heart condition after getting the vaccine (and there’s evidence that they are more likely to get the heart condition from an actual COVID-19 infection than from a vaccine)[1]. Before you repeat the “but young people” argument, an order of magnitude more young people have died from COVID-19 than have gotten that generally non-fatal Myocarditis heart condition after being vaccinated. So we know the risk factor of getting a vaccine is lower. [2]
Critical thinking is one thing, but there are a lot of bad faith actors in the “COVID skepticism” movement. Roughly speaking, vaccines have a near-zero chance of having averse side effects, a significant chance of reducing spread of COVID-19 (I myself am still skeptical about the studies which claim vaccinated people still spread the virus to unvaccinated people, since we’re generally seeing an exponential decrease in COVID-19 cases in places where a higher percentage of people are vaccinated), and greatly reduce hospitalizations of people who get COVID-19 [3].
It’s well known that, in the US, skepticism of vaccines and public health measures, unfortunately, have a political bias, and, lo and behold, people with a “COVID denial” (deny that masks help [4], refuse to take the vaccine, refuse to avoid large indoor social gatherings, etc.) political bent are much more likely to get a case of COVID-19 significant enough to report: https://i.redd.it/4o4i7arucpj71.png
A lot of this “skepticism” I am seeing reminds me of the young earth creationist arguments which I have seen over the years; they will take any evidence for a young earth, no matter how tenuous, and pretend it’s the one truth while ignoring all of the extensive evidence for an old earth. It’s bad faith arguing; young earth creationists and anti-vaxx “skeptics” do not argue in good faith.
This bad-faith skepticism -- which usually consists of poorly researched nonsense like claiming Myocarditis is a real concern if someone gets the vaccine -- is putting people in hospitals and bad-faith skepticism is killing people. I am having to avoid certain family members because they have drunk the kool-aid and refuse to vaccinate.
[1] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.07.23.21260998v...
[2] To address the “Rambo” argument that young people who do not have co-morbid conditions are unlikely to die from COVID-19, their chance of getting any adverse side effects from the vaccine is also very very low. See https://health.wusf.usf.edu/health-news-florida/2021-06-18/p...
[3] https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/5Qts7/9/
[4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7393808/ shows that masks do help
> There have been, from the total of 12,910,312 18-24 year-old people vaccinated, [2] about 229 cases of this rare heart disease (and, in almost all cases, the person was discharged from the hospital the same day with a clean bill of health) That means the vaccine has under a 0.002% chance of causing a very rare but not fatal heart condition.
The FDA has recorded[1] a rate of 0.0065% of Myocarditis cases and further estimates[2] a rate of up to 0.02% cases after vaccinations with the Pfizer vaccine, in the 16-17 male group. That risk appears to halve by age 25[3]. The rates with the Moderna vaccine may be higher still[4].
The common misrepresentation of Myocarditis as "mild" is concerning. In many cases, it leads to permanent heart damage, which in turn can lead to cardiac arrest later, significantly increasing mortality risk[5]. When undetected, acute Myocarditis can lead to cardiac arrest under stress, which is the leading causes of death in young athletes[6].
> I would rather take a 0.002% non-fatal risk than a 1.66% fatal risk
This is a population average, including co-morbidities, which is highly misleading. The CFR for males under 30 without co-morbidities in high-income countries has been estimated[7] at 0.0003%. At the other end, you have 80+ year males with co-morbidities at 20.08%.
[1] https://www.fda.gov/media/151733/download (Page 23)
[2] https://www.fda.gov/media/151733/download (Page 24)
[3] https://www.dicardiology.com/article/overview-myocarditis-ca...
[4] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-probing-moderna-vaccine-...
[5] https://jcmr-online.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1532-...
[6] https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/sudden-cardia...
[7] https://www.cgdev.org/sites/default/files/predicted-covid-19... (Page 6)
Yes, it does. I pointed out that the chance of getting Myocarditis is 0.002%, i.e. near zero. I also pointed out, and I repeat myself, that there have been 2,630 deaths from COVID-19 for 18-29 year olds (never mind the suffering COVID-19 causes people in this age range) [1]. Something that causes 2,630 deaths is more risky than something causing 229 non-fatal hospital visits.
I also observe you’re quoting stuff which uses estimated risks. The 229 number is a real risk: That’s the number of people who actually got Myocarditis after being vaccinated, a fact you conveniently ignored. To argue that a theoretical risk buried in a report (which correctly felt the risk was very small and approved the vaccine) trumps a real world figure we now have is downright disingenuous bad faith arguing.
Going back to your parent post, you allege that the pre-print paper https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.07.23.21260998 doesn’t “consider that actual COVID infections may be undercounted [sic]” (your words). Did you even read the paper?? Let me quote it: “In the United States, there is no national data on infection rate by age. According to a systematic review and the working assumption of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, children may have infection rates similar to adults, with younger people having more mild or asymptomatic cases. Accordingly, we used the estimated 9.2% population infection rate for April 2020 - March 2021.”
In other words, no they didn’t just look at case numbers, they made a reasonable estimate of actual infection figures, and based on those estimated figures said that one is six times more likely to get Myocarditis from COVID-19 itself than from a vaccination.
Now, it’s possible that a random Ycombinator poster has a better estimate for the number of total COVID-19 infections than a team of scientists writing a paper about COVID-19 and submitting it to peer review, but I’m not holding my breath here.
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1191568/reported-deaths-...
> Something that causes 2,630 deaths is more risky than something causing 229 non-fatal hospital visits.
This over-represents the risk groups. As you can see from the source[7] I posted, there's a massive difference between those with risk factors and those without.
> I also observe you’re quoting stuff which uses estimated risks. The 229 number is a real risk
The "229 number" is a number you took out of an outdated newspaper article. The FDA has recorded[2] (not estimated) a risk of 0.0065%.
> To argue that a theoretical risk buried in a report (which correctly felt the risk was very small and approved the vaccine) trumps a real world figure we now have is downright disingenuous bad faith arguing.
Let's not go down that "bad faith" route. You've been throwing around plenty of misleading numbers, but I don't think you're doing it in bad faith.
The FDA itself has found a "worst case" scenario[2] of low incidence that showed the risk/benefit ratio was not in favor of the vaccine, using efficacy estimates that may or may not reflect reality further down the road. This was then pushed aside by purported risks of longer observed hospital stays, but ignoring the long-term risk factors of Myocarditis. This is entirely speculative, at which point people risk believing whatever they want to be true, not what is actually true.
[2] https://www.fda.gov/media/151733/download (Page 24)
[7] https://www.cgdev.org/sites/default/files/predicted-covid-19... (Page 6)
At https://data.cdc.gov/Vaccinations/COVID-19-Vaccination-Demog... we see 11,776,463 vaccines administered to 12-17 year olds. Using math: 765 cases, which are generally non-fatal.
Using https://data.cdc.gov/NCHS/Provisional-COVID-19-Deaths-by-Sex... we get 1,131 fatalities among 15-24 year olds.
This, again, is 12-17 year olds; I was using figures for young adults before, where the chance of getting Myocarditis is smaller and the chance of dying from COVID-19 is larger.
The worst case figures for vaccine side effects you have been able to come up with is that the number of Myocarditis cases is about the same as the number of COVID-19 deaths in the adolescent age group, as as per the FDA paper you brought up “available data from short-term follow up [of Myocarditis cases] suggest that most individuals have had resolution of symptoms”. Even here, I would prefer a condition which gets resolved over something which would kill me.
I know you don’t like me making bad faith assumptions, but in the real world, people who argue against getting vaccinated usually argue in bad faith, and the results of their arguments are increased deaths because people didn’t get the vaccine. As I posted elsewhere in this thread, it’s well known that, in the US, skepticism of vaccines and public health measures, unfortunately, are bad faith arguments being made with a political bias, and, lo and behold, people with a “COVID denial” political bent are much more likely to get a case of COVID-19 significant enough to report: https://i.redd.it/4o4i7arucpj71.png [1] Also, well over 95% of COVID-19 hospitalizations are from unvaccinated people: https://datawrapper.dwcdn.net/5Qts7/9/
[1] The image is on Reddit, but the figures are from New York Times’s COVID-19 tracker and MIT Election Lab figures. My own graphs comparing COVID-19 infection rates in red states (states with right-wing governors) vs. blue states (left-wing governors) shows a much smaller COVID-19 Delta surge in places less “vaccine skeptical”; compare https://samiam.org/COVID-19/redStates.html and https://samiam.org/COVID-19/blueStates.html
So, before we talk any further, I need to know this: Did you get the COVID-19 vaccine? If not, why not? I will not reply to you until I know whether you have been vaccinated.
People who don't get vaccinated generally say it's because they don't trust the government. Probably because the government has proven time again to be untrustworthy. It's not just right wingers like the news is insinuating (another untrustworthy group), but all sides of the political spectrum and all demographics have people who are afraid to get vaccinated. No amount of scolding from you will change their mind, and COVID is probably here to stay, so you should adapt to that truth.
As to my motivations, I'm fully vaccinated.
And they should adapt to the truth that as long as there are COVID outbreaks, there are going to be epidemic adaptations. And that as long as they are the cause of those adaptations, public sentiment will increasingly shift towards making those adaptations targeted against anti-vaxxers.
One of those adaptations should be getting COVID patients out of hospitals, where they are infecting other people, disrupting ER services and scheduled surgeries, and into field hospitals. Every bed that is currently going to deal with a trivially preventable disease is multiple life-saving surgeries that aren't getting done. It would be nice if we could end this year with a working medical system.
If people want to free-load, that's fine, but we shouldn't be throwing scheduled passengers off the plane to make room for them.