Please stop adding more lanes to busy highways – it doesn’t help
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
If four lanes can handle 10,000 cars an hour at 45mph and six lanes can handle 15,000 cars an hour at 45mph then induced demand pointer-outers will point out that this doesn't help the traffic. And this is true! But clearly if the goal is for a city to get as much cars through as possible + make as many houses in the range of distance that can commute this is a plus.
This creates lots of problems with carbon waste and sprawl but I think looking at the traffic issue alone doesn't capture the full picture. It's like telling a restaurant that has an average wait time of 20 minutes that if they build 50% more tables and improve their wait staff that they will still have 20 minute wait times on Friday. This is true - but the wait time being held constant while drastically increasing capacity accomplishes the stated goals. And I have a hunch a lot of this criticism probably comes from a place of wealthier people who live within a very short distance of their place of work.
Take Atlanta for instance, something that would actually help traffic would be to build bypasses with no on ramps that circle the city. Every time they build a new loop so that truck traffic can bypass, more houses are built near that loop.
Clearly you can't build enough roads to satisfy this relationship to the point the physical distance the car can reasonably travel in a day is the limiter instead of the number of cars that can make it should there be a road available to fit them which is why it's not an answer for congestion in large cities but it can be the answer to capacity into target cities (barring enough support for more efficient means like mass transport).
But I don't think that is the goal of the people building the highways. They are thinking of how to maximize the economic output of a city + connect people to areas they currently have no access to. In your example it is a huge win for the city that new houses can be built in areas that have quick access to the highway and therefore the city. You (the incumbent) may not benefit but the number of people that now have a similarly nice experience to the people that already live close enough to the city to have access will increase.
https://www.cato.org/blog/debunking-induced-demand-myth
The paper compared daily kilometers of interstate highway driving with lane kilometers of interstates in the urbanized portions of 228 metropolitan areas. In the average metropolitan area, it found that between 1983 and 1993 lane miles grew by 32 percent while driving grew by 77 percent. Between 1993 and 2003, lane miles grew by 18 percent, and driving grew by 46 percent.
That's hardly a "perfect one-to-one relationship."
The paper also calculated the elasticities of driving in relationship to lane kilometers. An elasticity of 2 would mean a 10 percent increase in lane miles would correspond with a 20 percent growth in driving; an elasticity of 1 would mean that lane miles and driving would track closely together. The paper found that elasticities were very close to 1 with standard errors of around 0.05. Even though this is contradicted by the previously cited data showing that driving grew much faster than lane miles, this is the source of Turner's "perfect one-to-one relationship."
Looking at the same years as Duranton & Turner, in more than 90 percent of urban areas, driving grew far faster than lane miles. On average, driving grew more than twice as fast as lane miles. But in Boston between 1983 and 1993, freeway capacities grew by less than 1 percent, while driving grew by more than 35 percent. In Madison, capacities grew by 35 percent, while driving grew by less than 20 percent. The wide range in differences between urban areas suggests that, not only are Duranton & Turner's elasticities wrong, their standard errors are far too low.
I never thought of it as providing me with freedom, instead it felt like a necessary ball and chain. Now I can go where I please for peanuts with no worries and no constraints (eg always having to go back to where I parked).
But public transport needs to be excellent and affordable for this to work.
I get more done in 7 lanes of rush hour traffic in California than anywhere else.