6% Ain’t Really That Much
mattmaroon.com
mattmaroon.com
I'm not making a value judgement here --- maybe YC is worth that much for you.
(I read the article, I know "6%" isn't really the point here; it's just the one nit I have with the discussion.)
At that stage (where cash compensation is minimal if not non-existent), the equity that would need to be given a real "rock star" would be considerably higher.
The idea that you can just keep peeling 6% (or 40%) every round is also a fallacy. You can keep doing that exactly until the point where your shareholders stop letting you do it.
Again: it's really easy to devise an argument that says a YC endorsement is worth 6%. I'm not going there. I'm just asking you to think about the real value of that equity number, and I'm doing that because I think to a lot of people, 6% sounds low. I had less than 2% of a very small company that got acquired in '98, and I ended that year just shy of 7 figures.
If a company in the idea stage were to hire a rock star, they'd almost always need to give way more than 1 or 2%. A company that's already gone through YC and/or done an angel round might give away that little.
And even then, bringing on a CEO would be way more. You wouldn't want a CEO to only get 1 or 2% equity.
I would say that for most first timer's though, it's a clear win. If nothing else, PG's guidance probably saves you from well more than 6% wasted equity later on.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=280082
(jk)