Thank 'This American Life' and ask them to set an example
fsf.org
fsf.org
https://developer.android.com/guide/appendix/media-formats.h...
https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/VLC_media_pla...
And asking someone to use an un-patent-encumbered format is radicalism? Isn't that what google is doing?
Revolution begins at home, but it is sad that for most of us it ends there too. TAL is in a unique position to actually do something about this, and you'd think they would when you consider the tone of their program.
Ira Glass has the ears of more people than RMS or Brett Smith...
And in any case, I don't see why this makes patent reformists lose credibility. They didn't stay stop offering mp3s, they said offer free formats. You're putting words in their mouths.
And, in case FSF hasn't been paying attention, WebM isn't looking too unencumbered right now. If Ogg ever becomes economically significant, it will probably end up in the same boat.
As others have said, we need to balance idealism and practicality. E.g. providing real audio feeds (which many NPR shows and the BBC used to) is Just Plain Stupid. But while MP3 may not be perfect it (a) works (b) everywhere and (c) doesn't cost the end-user anything.
We shouldn't be using patent-free file formats, that have made compromises to be patent-free. We should be fighting to end patents (except for medicine). The best thing we can ask This American Life, or ProPublica, or Planet Money, or Marketplace to do, is to air more shows about the problems patents cause.
This type of act by the FSF is the type of thing that gets some guy at the office to say, "I told you. These people just want you to use Ogg on your Linux computer running on some patent unecumbered CPU (couldn't think of one). They're just not realistic."
The reason being that it takes a lot of time and money to bring a new drug to market. Hundreds of millions in many cases. And the cost to create a generic version is very low. Think tens of thousands. And the time even lower (think weeks).
So you have a situation where you can spend $300M over 5 years to create a new drug (due to various regulations in bringing a drug to market), which will have generic competition in two months after release. That makes doing that type of drug research a non-starter. It's not like the drug maker can just keep improving the drug.
That doesn't happen in most other industries, where your 1 year of research and development largely gives you a 3-6 month advantage (you can release whatever you want, whenever you want). And you can then continue to improve the product at a brisk rate, building on what you've done. Google today is not the Google from a decade ago. They've taken their technology and improved it at a rapid rate, such that the current product is magnitudes better. You can't do that for most drugs.
I, however, don't know enough about alternative business models to say if they make any sense.
This is a really nasty way to make a point.
The FSF has the time and people to advocate many things, including this, while still focusing on other goals.
Will the FSF no longer be against the MP3 format once all the patents expire?
Isn't one of the biggest problems with the mp3 format the fact that there are multiple patents owned by multiple corporations in different markets? According to [1] some have expired but there are tons more that haven't. It is also not surprising that the East Texas District mentioned in TAL has been used to settle a lawsuit involving the use of the mp3 format[2].
[1]http://www.tunequest.org/a-big-list-of-mp3-patents/20070226/
[2]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MP3#Licensing_and_patent_issues
[1] I find it really odd, based on the headline, that the article doesn't even mention this possibility.
The story was mostly about how new software--like Ogg--inadvertently infringes on overly broad patents even if was developed in isolation. In what way does promoting Ogg solve that?