It is possible to have sensible debate without immediately putting people into the blue or red team. We can do better than this.
It is possible to have sensible debate without immediately putting people into the blue or red team. We can do better than this.
I say this acknowledging that the actual criticisms here are reasonable and I don't have any particular disdain for the post or the discussion, just that I am totally unsurprised that you picked up on it being oddly insular.
The only purpose of labeling people based on a particular belief/position is to make it easier to attack with generalizations, and polarize the debate. Now you have to pick a side - are you a degrowther or not?
There are reasons to labeling people other than those you suggest. For example, maybe it simply was the first way to express his argument that came to mind. Or maybe, identifying a group of people who think X can be part of the debate. For example, suppose libertarians are all funded by billionaires. That might suggest a motivation for libertarian thought. You couldn't know this without identifying the people who are libertarians.
Lastly, it's often good that people have to "pick a side". Do you think we should aim to stop economic growth, or don't you? It's good that you should come to a clear position on this topic. Unclear positions might be nuanced, yes. But they might also be based on unclear thinking, or a desire to please everybody.
Anecdotally, I quickly tire from reading or hearing arguments full of the polarization labels (liberal/conservative/neocon/neoliberal/etc). Wonder if I’m alone in this.
That’s such an anti-teamer thing to say.