Not sure I understand this, do you mean you would use something that had the exact same feature set, if the internal architecture was different and if someone else was maintaining it? What would be the point of that? Are there some performance or security improvements to the architecture that were suggested upstream that they aren't doing?
>narrower scope
Not sure I understand this either, the scope of journald is actually quite small, there are many syslog implementations that are bigger and have a lot more features.