Hacker News Reader

Comment by Nagyman | Hacker News Reader

You can just submit a blank ballot.

https://www.quora.com/As-voting-is-compulsory-in-Australia-a...

I don’t see this as anywhere near the same thing though. These so called ‘donkey votes’ are derided, and categorised as together with voting errors and other invalid voting forms. The right to withhold your vote is as fundamental as the right to withold your labour. Voter turnout is an important metric in its own right, and is observed tactically in, say, the UK. Compulsory voting simplifies competition, and destroys some forms of it. In particular, the ‘mandate’

> In particular, the ‘mandate’

The amount of electorates that swung, and the percentages that the winning representative (and party) received mean that's not true at all, in my opinion anyway. Happy to be convinced otherwise, but the "mandate" still exists.

I highly doubt most non-voters are intentionally "witholding" their vote. I think it's more often just laziness or lack of access (voting during work day etc.).

It has to be incredibly more meaningful to have statistics on how many people intentionally said "screw you" with a vote for "ficus" or w/e.

And in democracies like the UK, people who don’t vote are disregarded as lazy and ignored too.

I agree, you should be able to withhold as a protest, in practice it’s 100% meaningless.

They aren’t ignored - parties try to woo them over.

In a system where there are many more parties, and ballots can still be spoiled, I don't see how that would be different.

A donkey vote isn't a blank ballot.

It's a ballot that's just been numbered unthinkingly from top to bottom.

Are they counted as votes? That would mean the person at the top of the ballot have an advantage because of these donkey votes.

Yes, they are counted, because it is a perfectly valid vote.

This does indeed advantage the candidate who draws the top spot on the ballot (the positions are randomly assigned). In a preferential system it advantages the candidate in the final two that drew the higher position - it seems to be worth about 0.7% ( https://www.crikey.com.au/2010/08/02/whats-the-donkey-worth-... ).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com