I think part of the confusion is, if the product is what they claim it is, it already exists with a multitude of other companies.
There’s a US company named Celsius in NY that already offers fixed interest for crypto and loans. Ethereum has a dozen different defi options for lending out crypto. This isn’t some new thing that the SEC has never seen before.
It seems weird that if the SEC intends to use that ruling that they haven’t yet applied it to any of the existing products on the market or at the very least released a guidance.