California moves to be the first state to outlaw 'stealthing'
usatoday.com
usatoday.com
...so all this does is make it explicitly a civil violation, making it easier for women to sue perpetrators for damages.
Civil court has a significantly lower bar for evidence than criminal court, so I wonder if this will be abused using false accusations.
Why?
Even if we treat California in 2021 and California in 2017 as a single unitary actor here, it is quite possible to think “stealthing” (not currently a felony, maybe arguably included in a misdemeanor but never prosecuted, and not clearly actionable under civil law) is underpunished and ought to at least be made clearly subject to civil liability, while also thinking that knowing exposure to HIV (prior to 2017 explicitly a felony) was overpunished, and ought only to be treated criminally as a misdemeanor, and only when there is intent to infect (the same as knowing exposure to other communicable diseases.)
Yes.
> Would it not just be considered rape?
No, as stated in the article it might arguably be misdemeanor sexual battery (not rape, which is a felony) under existing criminal law, but it is essentially never prosecuted as such. Making it unambiguously subject to civil liability provides some clearly-available remedy, and one which does not rely on public prosecutors deciding to prioritize the act.
Much easier to hit someone with civil liabilities, especially if you prove they have a pattern of things 'falling off'.