The thing I constantly find weird about California regulation these days is how short sighted and micro-managey it all is. This one clearly is explicitly targeted at Amazon, the AB5/Prop 22 pair is specifically targeted at Uber/Lyft, etc.
It strikes me as a deep lack of understanding about how policy making is supposed to work. Ideally, policy is supposed to be something you get experts to research holistically, present data on and implement based on certain expectations of how pros and cons are supposed to play out. California policy making looks to me more like a reactive game of whack-a-mole, trying to put out whatever is the fire du jour with hacks and bandaids and hoping the new rules don't cause any collateral damage.
And if you look at Universities, well good luck. They have a known ideological bent that would cause recommendations that are skewed the other way.
I think the underlying problem is that these employers have disproportionate power, influence, and resources, along with endless creativity. If they can't get the government fully on their side every time, they'd rather it be dysfunctional.
I was thinking exactly this while reading this article. I was really hoping to read that this was a much more generic law that strengthens worker protections, that also just happens to help with the problems in Amazon warehouses. But, nope, just feels like "injustice whack-a-mole". That's not a good way to develop policy at all.
These are corporations with more power than nation states with CEO's having more personal power than many dictators.
If you want generic laws, then break up these companies into smaller ones.
The way the quotas get set is kind of as a bell curve. You set quotas, including threshold for promotions, as some where you'll get let go. They hire people, and those folks thrive to meet the quota/make more money. If everyone is doing so well that the tip of the bell curve is too much to the right, they increase the quota. If they have trouble hiring and everyone's leaving, or if they end up needing to let go too many people, they lower it.
Of course, a company could push it way too far if they have enough power and a big enough employee pool. They can then put super high quotas and only keep people who can push it that far (probably where the whole "peeing in bottles" come from).
The concept itself isn't that weird. Maybe weird to people who mostly worked in salaried jobs that are hard to quantify.
Where it becomes a problem is when too many people are desperate enough for money that they're willing to literally harm themselves to meet their quotas or get promoted. That's probably where regulators came from with this type of law. I didn't read it, but that sounds really tough to implement.
Universal healthcare and UBI are would enable much more employer freedom in defining working conditions.
Living has always required energy, effort, and skill. How can we get around this without some sort of parasitic relationship? Do you have any recommendation for some reading for a sustainable model? From my understanding, UBI is largely unproven.
So people will still want to work. But they no longer are forced to take any job just to survive.
I'm sorry I don't have reading recommendations. This doesn't mean they don't exist, I am just not deep enough into this topic to ever have looked for them.
We'd need to, as a society, draw a line in the sand as to what "the basics" are (it's extremely subjective. I think MIT or Harvard has a site with threshold they consider the minimum, but it uses arbitrary metric like expected amount of kids, and it's by city).
Once we pick, while we should always be ready to revisit, it can't be a constant thing. If folks are robbing CVS saying they wouldn't if UBI was higher (assuming it was set to a reasonable amount to begin with. A big if), we're not much better off than where we are now.
It seem that far to often management just keep increasing the productivity requirements, squeezing more and more blood from the stones of the workforce with zero regard for the health and wellbeing of the regular employees.
See https://www.scribd.com/document/407590982/Amazon-Termination...
Scroll down to "The system also tracks an associates time off task" It basically admits that "time off task" doesn't automatically account for bathroom breaks. You have to ask a manager to include each one, during the conversation where you're being scolded for high "time off task"! The wording in this section is Amazon's wording, too. Oof.
Edit: After a bit of searching, there don't appear to be any federal laws requiring breaks in the US, and there are many states that don't have any either.
Breaks are legally mandated a lot of places where people don't get them. I've known many hundreds of people that have worked in many thousands of restaurants in all positions in the northeast cities— NY, Boston, etc. Breaks for restaurant workers— aside from 5ish minute cigarette breaks— though legally mandated, are nearly unheard of. More often than not, the much exalted 'family meal' is cheap leftovers eaten while standing up in a back hallway or while doing other work.
It's also very common for cooks to be given rules like "don't punch in more than 30 minutes before service, or punch out more than 30 minutes after service" even though you've got 2+ hours of setup and cleanup which you'll get fired for not completing. It's obviously not legal, but restaurant back of the house workers are so disempowered on a whole, that it really doesn't matter.
If you're interested in seeing more about the local restaurant work culture, check out the saga of a Boston-based pizza chain "The Upper Crust." Their brazenness was based in experience for how these things were generally handled. The fact that they were punished for their behavior is the exception rather than the rule. Almost all restaurant work complaints that get sent to the AG are ignore. I know because I've sent 4, personally, for outright wage theft and know many others that sent complaints in for similar problems.
This is obviously not true in corporate environments with more uniform employment policies.
I saw a Polish kapo beat someone who said he was too sick to work. It's almost a concentration camp out there but most of the public will never know. One day we will run out of folks to exploit but until then full steam ahead I suppose.
I was friends/coworkers with a 19 year old Mexican American mom who had just extricated herself from a small, c-grade traveling circus in Texas. A few months after joining them, the ringmaster woke her up every morning demanding she start training on the trapeze immediately, and would punch her in the stomach every day she refused. She was 16 years old and pregnant.
Check out this Frontline documentary on labor trafficking in the us:
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/inside-the-hidden...
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/trafficked-in-americ...
If every worker would just take their breaks, and allow their quotas to slip, what is Amazon going to do? Fire everyone? But instead, individuals decide to look out for themselves first, and defect, which causes everyone to be miserable, including themselves.
I don't blame them in the slightest for this, but it still makes me sad. I guess this is what unions are for. Oh wait, Amazon engages in union-busting, never mind.
Lets give them a quota in attention points to point out - or be fired.
Reminds me of when people were claiming ADA exemptions for masks, as a "loophole". Then folks involved in the ADA point out it wasn't a loophole, because it was illegal to claim an exemption if you have a real condition.
Except the way laws like the ADA and HIPAA are written, it's literally impossible in most cases to check if someone is lying or not. So unless you're ready to literally gamble on your guts feeling (they can't sue you for discrimination if it was indeed false, but you have no way to check!), you couldn't do anything.
But hey, it's against the law, so I'm sure people won't lie.