"Against Intellectual Monopoly" by Boldwin & Levine refutes the argument about patents enabling innovation during the industrial revolution. In fact, the innovation on the steam engine itself was stifled by the original Watt patent.
This is a good video on this (about how the steam engine, the light bulb, Ford automobiles, and other breakthrough inventions came to life):
If it is not possible to keep something secret, patents would only help if people otherwise really would keep inventions secret. But there are ways to gain even without secrecy -- first-mover advantage, etc. -- and inventors would be attracted to those rather than nothing at all.
If it is possible to keep something secret, then those motivated by the gains from patents would choose secrecy in preference, since secrecy is an even stronger monopoly.