I hate this selective criticism; for goodness' sake, she was the CEO of reddit -- a company with ethical controversies every other week, but she attacks MailChimp? Give me a break.
I hate this selective criticism; for goodness' sake, she was the CEO of reddit -- a company with ethical controversies every other week, but she attacks MailChimp? Give me a break.
There is no substance to the objection. They aren't entitled to anything, they didn't negotiate anything, and they shouldn't get anything. Her argument is akin to saying that the Uber driver that dropped me off at the gas station is entitled to part of my lottery winnings because the ticket I bought happened to have the jackpot numbers.
The position is both logically inconsistent and severely asymmetrical—we are only talking about this because MailChimp did have a successful exit, not because they failed miserably (as literally hundreds of startups do on a yearly basis). Even as a staunch capitalist, I'll be the first to say there are plenty of problems with corporate tax law, offshore tax havens, money laundering, etc.
But this ain't one.
At a point in time before Mailchimp was clearly a success (and thus equity would actually be worth something), most engineers would jump at a salary-over-equity compensation scheme because it's common knowledge (at least around here) that equity is a lottery ticket that usually doesn't pay off.
Anything else and you're a chump. Since there are a whole lot of employee #50, and #35, and #110s out there apparently many people really don't know what they are getting into.
From a strict compensation perspective, you are probably right, but even then, it is probably less stark than it was ten years ago, what with seed rounds and series A sizes being so massive that salaries are a bit more reasonable at this stage too.
As another commenter pointed out, there was obviously a fair agreement here: work for Mailchimp at X salary and no equity, or don't. Nobody was forced into anything, and if no equity was offered, then I'm sure the salaries had to be competitive in the market. Nobody would be stupid enough to work for them otherwise.
From reading the room I’d say Ellen Pao is typically seen as a minor villain around here. Definitely not a hero.
They have no reason to be unhappy and MailChimp doesn’t owe them anything other than the salary and profit sharing that was promised. Regardless of who the new owners of MailChimp are.
There are multiple other possible motivations for Ellen’s post other than criticism.
https://twitter.com/Shubham/status/1437532055173226499
Ellen Pao sucks. Didn't she fire a Reddit employee who had cancer?
and this is why i'm against unions in tech - the people like she will be the bosses.
That is the thing, we are seeing an extreme negative view of basic capitalism, people tend to believe founders and capital have no value believing in a socialist utopia where by all the workers get an equal share of the "means of production"