This is what's gonna happen to a whole lot of modern games. What a waste.
Only pirates can help them.
This is what's gonna happen to a whole lot of modern games. What a waste.
Only pirates can help them.
Usually with enough dedication you can track down and hack out the activated code - and if an old DRM system falls into disuse a lot of companies will just release the details on it making it even easier to patch out.
In summary I would say that the coverage is a lot more complete than you'd expect :)
To use a sports analogy here, do you think it really matters to football coaches that the players can't go back in time and play the game exactly as it was played 100 years ago, for various reasons? The equipment and safety practices have changed, the old fields have been rebuilt or destroyed, the minutiae of the rules have changed quite a bit over time, etc. People could try to do a historical re-enactment of sorts, it wouldn't be the same, but that's okay because the game would still be fun if it was done the right way.
But now... 5 different subscriptions, and still unable to get the show you want,... yeah, not anymore.
I remember the Battlefield 2 community tried to revive the multiplayer servers after GameSpy shut down.
EA sent them a C&D.
EDIT: it's impossible to make money off of digital goods without artificial scarcity. This is because data is naturally not scarce. In the beginning, physical media allowed data goods to piggy-back on the retail structures already in place. Personal computing and the internet has mostly eliminated that form of scarcity. New forms of scarcity have been invented, some better than others (from the end-user perspective). Note that this truth applies to FAANG as well. Facebook and Google's fortunes have been built on the scarcity of ad space. Gaming companies have invented ways to create scarcity ranging from account-bound DRM (Steam, Battle.net), dongles, and always-on phone-home requirement for the runtime. And more. All of these technologies exist to extract money from something that is naturally not scarce. And rather than hate that fact, consider that without the ability to extract monetary value, these projects would not have been executed in the first place. So what's worse: a world in which we have excellent games hobbled by money extraction mechanisms, or a world in which we don't have excellent games? I know which one I prefer.
Maybe I haven't had enough coffee, but I don't think I understand.
You can't just quit your day job, live off your savings for a bit, and make a game like this. You need a big team with funding set up ahead of time, and that finding won't be released - either by external investors or management at a studio - unless you expect to make a return on that investment.
That said, I'm not sure "artificial scarcity" is the right way to think about this. No company is making money off of five year old games. The fact that they connect to an ad server has nothing to do with creating artificial scarcity, it's just another revenue stream for the game company.
GTA 5 came out in 2013 and sold 20 million copies last year. Several games sold better after 5 years than most others at release.
Are you saying that if old games didn't eventually break because people didn't maintain them, new games wouldn't be made?
I was active in gaming in the early-mid CD-ROM era and saw this in practice. If something can be trivially pirated (copy the files on the disc to a new one) it will be copied like wildfire. If it takes a bit more effort (bad sectors that make naive copying fail, etc.) then piracy won't go away but will become rarer. As the effort to pirate becomes more intense, if buying it is easier people will. If ads let you drop the price to a point where it's more affordable, more people will choose to pay it. Etc.
The reason you see alternative monetization is because it is so damn profitable, not because it is needed simply to fund the games. Look at Warzone, brings in $5.2M per day. There are countless other examples.
Investors want to go where there is maximum profit. But that doesn't mean we need these schemes just for the games to exist.
Companies like Sony still do it, but Sony gets a cut of every transaction on their platform, so they have their regular income as well.
Microsoft has sort of figured out a solution with gamepass where they can make large offers to devs in order to minimise their risk.
Whole industry is shifting towards it.