https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil#Un...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piercing_the_corporate_veil#Un...
You can't just go "maybe discovery in this civil case will reveal the criminal conspiracy" and then go "eh, guess not".
I am almost certain that the Sacklers thought they were producing drugs which would relieve pain and help end-users live happier and more productive lives. This may have been self-deception, but I don't have the knowledge to do a cost-benefit analysis of this situation (though I'd be interested to see one on opiods).
It's much easier to convict the corporation than its members.
People do get convicted of misconduct at a corporation. It's just that in some (most?) instances, the criminality is so diffuse that you can't convict anyone of anything, so you end up convicting the corporation instead.
I am not a lawyer, but I don't think the state needs to prove intent to kill. It could have been negligence, eg they knew people were getting addicted but declined to change their aggressive marketing tactics.
what are you expecting to turn up? Documents/recordings that say "yep we totally knew that oxycotin was addictive and we're moving profits out with the goal of hiding them from creditors"?
[1] https://www.justice.gov/opa/press-release/file/1329736/downl...
The investment banker's advice was "the one thing you don’t want to do is to become poor". Purdue Pharma going under wouldn't make them poor. So it couldn't mean the latter.
Sackler referred to the Virginia courtroom where Purdue Pharma's parent company admitted to fraud and agreed to pay $600 million. And "all of these courtrooms". Not to operating losses or any such thing.
> Is the state going to convince the jury of that better than the defense?
There's 1 way to find out.
Just like with tons of other cases, the actual thing people trip on are entirely ancillary -- tax evasion, wire fraud, embarrassing emails, obstruction of justice. I'll bet there are a dozen obstruction of justice charges that can be levied if you search thru emails.
Again, they are getting white-glove treatment, so we havent bothered to look for the stuff that will force a more reasonable settlement for the millions of innocent victims.
And the response to that is that they're well funded to resist those attacks by the government, so it will end up being a drain on resources on both sides. legal MAD, if you will.
But we also have laws around when they can and can't be applied. There are standards of evidence and suspicion that must be reached. Due process exists even for billionaires. Also, prosecutors or investigators might not use those tools if they doubt useful evidence would be uncovered.
Certainly this sounds weird, but there's very clear president. OJ Simpson was both acquitted in criminal court and convicted in a civil suit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O._J._Simpson_murder_case#Civi...
The precedence that we will not tolerate crimes as a path to unimaginable wealth is worth more than they could bankroll.
Just my opinion, but the only justice here is to take their wealth away. A prison sentence is pretty meaningless unless they're in for life, which of course we all know a few years is the more likely reality (and I'm not advocating for life either).
The reason I say "real" is because even if we meant to take "all" of their wealth, what are the chances we actually get all of it? And without getting all of it, a seemingly negligible amount of cash, like 10MM which is <0.1% relative to >10,000MM, can still make the crime "worth it."
Morally, absolutely. The Sacklers cannot be allowed to walk away with billions AND immunity from future suits.
Further, at least in Canada, parliament can institute ex post facto laws by invoking the nothwithstanding clause. Always a little hairy politically, but legal and compatible with the rule of law.
[edit] I would further argue that ex post facto laws in general are immoral.
In this case, is there a more moral solution that remains within the realm of legal? Perhaps not, but I'd like the JD to try, since the proposed solution strikes me as allowing the Sackler family to profit massively off immoral activities.
IMO (as a layman, not a lawyer), I'm unclear on why a corporate bankruptcy settlement involves immunity for the Sacklers. If we are not allowed to pierce the corporate veil, it should go both ways. If they want to keep their fortunes, they should remain open to civil suits. Alternatively, they can forfeit the vast majority of their fortunes in return for immunity from future suits.
Interested to see other replies re: your comment!