This. Unlimited PTO is kind of a scam. Then again, I think most experienced devs know this. Come on, would a company really offer you
unlimited PTO? No.
That said, I feel like I do have quite a lot of PTO and I feel free to take it. Having that confidence requires having an employer that gives you feedback on your performance and knowing that you've 'earned' the time off.
Even at companies with fixed PTO, there are still times when you just know taking the time off would be career suicide. Taking time off near a planned release date is just insulting to other team members.
There's a story I keep going back to that I think is useful here. Way back, 20 years ago, working for a newly acquired division of WindRiver, we had an informal policy where you just got your work done and could come and go as you pleased. A couple of young, new engineers weren't comfortable with the informal policy and asked for clarification during a company meeting with upper management. Of course the official answer was that you got X days off and it required managerial approval and blah blah blah. Fortunately middle-management continued to look the other way and allowed the informal system to continue. Sometimes there are unwritten rules in business. These are, unfortunately, often unfair for new engineers and under-represented groups who don't feel secure enough in their positions to take advantage of them. I'm not sure how I feel about that. On the one hand, I like the quid-pro-quo system but I do understand that some people, especially engineers, have trouble with vagueness.