Writing clear code is superior to writing "cute" code, and "return i++" is a case of the latter. In any case where the increment actually matters you are directly affecting a shared state and such changes should be made contextually obvious to the state of the object--one's neck would need to be very, very beard to think that this is immediately obvious and apparent in a contextually valid way.
Similarly, for many programmers, myself included, a semicolon is read as a period is in English--the end of the statement. (You keep saying that "but people don't get annoyed at Python when it does it," and guess what? I certainly get annoyed at it--Python consistently frustrates me because I find it considerably less readable.) Omitting semicolons is less immediately clear than including them and, again, can be misconstrued. Only it can be misconstrued by the program interpreter, too. (Oops.)