What's the issue with dual monitors and GNOME?
But I think there is a general problem with sleep modes as mentioned. Luckily it boots in a fraction of the time Windows took.
Why would anyone not prefer this over a mixed set up? The only reason I see to use a mixed set up is if you're forced to use a laptop. Personally I don't optimize for working in meetings and planes though and my life is just simple and straightforward. I keep just 1 cheapo laptop around for that stuff.
With that said, XFCE handles mixed DPI/scaling just fine for me.