I certainly didn't want to frustrate anybody by posting what I did. If you like, I will delete what I posted on the StackOverflow page. Just say the word.
I certainly didn't want to frustrate anybody by posting what I did. If you like, I will delete what I posted on the StackOverflow page. Just say the word.
I think that would mean having browsers support a standard SRP protocol binding (eg http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc5054.txt) and then really nailing the browser user interface.
I could see using SRP as an alternative to private keys, or as a strong "something you know" factor in addition to private keys (a "something you have" factor) in order to establish ownership of an account.
However, this doesn't strike me as a credible first step in getting through the aforementioned "deployment deadlock" issue.
Completely aside from that, I'm not sure I see why you think browser support would be so much better of a solution, aside from having a more uniform interface. Combating phishing is primarily an issue of being intelligent about what sites you give your information to. Any decent form-based authentication system will send the data in an encrypted form, which will be as secure as data encrypted by the browser's built-in authentication system. Just having the browser as a middleman doesn't help if your data gets sent to or intercepted by the wrong people, and Firefox, at least, already has a good system for warning users about malicious sites.
Also, you wrote: "Just having the browser as a middleman doesn't help if your data gets sent to or intercepted by the wrong people".
Actually, having the browser more directly involved does help with this, because it can use strong authentication when negotiating a TLS session.
By "strong authentication", I mean the authentication protocol has security features which make it useful over an untrusted network in the presence of eavesdroppers or even active adversaries looking to pull off a man-in-the-middle attack.
Client certificates are a good example of this and are supported by today's browsers but there are UX problems there.
It's not that the forms-based system doesn't work. I just think it could be a lot better.
Just consider how much easier it is today to stay in a "walled garden" social network than to be an active commenter on a large number of independent blogs.