Do Danes ever advocate for someone to be fired?
If workers naturally have different productivity points, why protect their right to earn $22/hour?
Do Danes ever advocate for someone to be fired?
If workers naturally have different productivity points, why protect their right to earn $22/hour?
That makes no sense what so ever.
If you are not massively productive you don't deserve a living wage and should live in a cardboard box for being such a shameful existence.
That’s fine for a while, but what if it intrudes in personal life? What if the work doesn’t get done, say a power outage, sanitation issues, it can impact many people?
If that’s your colleague, what’s the recourse?
If the company can't pay the staff enough to live and can't afford to staff the amount of people they need, the company isn't viable.
At which point you can let the company suffer for it, or let the staff suffer for it.
If the company has to rely on people living in subhuman conditions to survive, the company should die.
But a more common scenario - what about a co-worker, that is 60% your capacity?
And the union and company agree that two people doing this job should be enough. No more hiring.
The person is not great at getting things done, but not horrible enough to be fired (especially by union standards).
They're stuck on your team.
While overtime pay is great, do you really want to be responsible every week for their work deficit?
What's the recourse in the Danish labor structure?
That’s not a thing in Denmark.
The person is not great at getting things done, but not horrible enough to be fired (especially by union standards).
That’s also not a thing. It’s surprisingly easy to fire workers in Denmark. It’s similar to at-will employment in the US. Only you’re not screwed if you do get fired, because we have generous unemployment benefits and universal healthcare.
Is it a thing in Denmark where a company doesn't have enough revenue to hire an additional workers? And you're stuck doing the surplus because of a low output co-worker?
To me, protection isn't love.
Workers that don't measure up aren't a good fit. Fire them. So that they can be set free, become stronger, at something they are good at.
A worker at McDonald's that does 60% the output of the rest of the team doesn't deserve $22/hr.
Oh, but I agree! Fun fact: It’s surprisingly easy to fire workers in Denmark. This is relatively uncontroversial because 1. there is a severance period, which is usually at least three months, and 2. generous unemployment benefits. We call it Flexicurity[1].
Not if some workers are being paid more than their productivity/value is worth.
>You protect the right to make a decent living.
>the company can always fire a worker
These statements are contradictory.
Firing anyone not worth minimum wage makes the true minimum wage $0 = unemployment.
Which essentially prohibits anyone who's value is less than minimum wage from making any living at all, much less make a decent living.
Denmark is not communist. The state doesn’t mandate that you have to work for Mcdonalds and cannot work anywhere else. If a company doesn’t feel you are competent in a position then they can fire you, obviously. The minimum wage doesn’t mean they are obligated to pay anyone who wants to work for them, it simply means that anyone working in the position must have a wage at that point or above.
This notion that a "living wage" raises the floor for everyone is BS. The floor stays at zero and the height to the first step becomes unreachable for some.
What do you mean, "High risk"? And a negative history - is that the same as being fired or working short term for a bunch of jobs? I'm gonna guess there is a limit to how much of that job history folks can hold against you - and additionally, I get the impression that folks don't change jobs as often as they do in the US. (I'm an immigrant, so I get stuff wrong sometimes).
I'm pretty sure the job stability is due to a combination between there being less wage gap between people, strong worker protection laws, and not having things like health insurance dependent on your employment status.
Few folks are unemployable: There are assistance programs to help folks find work, after all.
Employees require investment beyond their wage, especially on the front end. If they quit or have to be fired before that pays off, it's a loss for the employer.
You seem to have an idealistic view of what employing someone is like.
Why would you hire a person for minimum wage if they weren't worth that value?
Even worse, they might require supervision / handholding by you or someone else, costing that additional amount as well. Maybe they're clumsy and break things. Maybe they are rude and run off customers.
That all costs money, and it's the tip of the iceberg.
Or they just simply might not be productive enough to cover their cost.
Pretending everyone is worth whatever peg you set as minimum wage is delusional.
Yes, you have to handhold sometimes. This is expected. If they aren't picking up on things in a reasonable time, places in the US will start disciplinary actions. The vast majority of people can do the stuff, though. Honestly, though, a lot of low wage jobs have some supervision built into the system, if anything to try to monitor theft or to keep folks from messing up.
Few people are so clumsy that they actually have issues. In the same vein, pretty much everyone is clumsy from time to time and very occasionally, someone will break something expensive. This is all rare. (I've worked many low wage jobs, and been in the middle management).
I don't know what sorts of jobs you think are low wage, but the vast majority simply don't have "productive enough". Some folks are slower than others, but realistically, there is only so much production you are going to do behind a cash register. Even things as arbitrary as how fast you help people isn't completely under your control.
I think people, just for being human and without having to prove worth, deserve a living wage and I think that should be more - at all times - than one would get from a safety net. If you work, you get x. If you think people are being overpaid at that rare, I would argue that's only because others that you deem "worth it" are underpaid.
The union decides who gets promoted, demoted - which is usually on the basis of 'time in' - and sets the rates for which jobs (and I mean exactly which jobs, i.e. you don't pick up a tool or do a task unless it's on paper that this task is 'your job').
FYI I'm speaking from the experience of a family member who was a Union Member at a Boeing plant - so this would be a fairly traditional late-20th century style North American Union, similar to auto-sector style unions.