Hacker News Reader

Comment by pitdesi | Hacker News Reader

Interesting that that post itself (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2864557) is now on the 2nd page despite having 400some upvotes in the past 7 hours (odd because there are several posts with many less votes in a similar timeframe on the homepage).

Does that happen due to being flagged too many times or some other reason?

View on HN

Speculation: there is an authority metric which is used as a strong quality indicator. If you're considered an authority then your vote counts a lot more.

7 votes from folks like patio11 counts for about a million votes by the likes of me.

Like I said, speculation.

I'm wondering also if some who down vote get a bigger down vote ratio. usually i lose points 1 by 1 and sometimes i just reload and lose 10 or more. Or that's cache. ;-)

And yeah I've strong opinions so while sometimes i get crazy upvotes I also get crazy downvotes hehe.

There's no down voting on articles. And for karma, 1 vote = 1 point.

I'm pretty sure it has to do with flagging. (that, as well, is speculation combined with personal observation).

Would norvig be on the list? aaronsw? I keep meaning to build a list of celebrity CS people on HN. Anybody already got one?

This would be a good start: http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders

What amazes me is that as much as I read HN, there are still people in the top 10 whose comments and submissions I've never seen. I wonder if they got all their karma years ago and it's taking this long for everyone else to catch up.

true to the word. " What would you believe , maximus?"

community tagging could not be the solution here- what do you think?

--Stackoverflow blog offers some explanation.

To be fair, some of them mostly submit stories (compare e.g. tptacek and fogus; the first has lots of comments but few stories, the other is the other way round.)

That's almost exactly what I'm not interested in. There are some very interesting people with account who post very infrequently, but their comments, in the context of who they are, is very interesting indeed.

So...we're Digg then?

Yikes...THAT wasn't the right to say

Reply on news.ycombinator.com