Hacker News Reader

The article is worse than parent commenter in sematics. It equates mindfulness with golfers 'paying attention to their swing' which is just plain wrong. Mindfulness is not focussing on an outcome, like hitting a golf ball exactly in the right way, but about understanding the breadth of experiences in the present - senses and thoughts.

It's like going to a discount store, browsing the isles and finding good deals here and there (fun random shopping), vs going to the mall to get that blue shirt with white lines, and never finding it in the right size in any store (an often frustrating experience).

The difference is in how you filter your experiences - wide filter with no specific purpose is mindful state, narrow filter with exact purpose is regular state.

A simple test: in mindful states you are very aware of the body and in regular states you forget about it.

Please elaborate what arguing semantics means to you in this context.

The comment above seems very relevant to me. Sure, mindfulness (meditation?) can be both.

Still, the signposts point primarily not to thinking as the driver of doing (being), but to awareness itself.

> You can and should practice both.

Yes.