Geometric proof that angle trisection by straightedge and compass is impossible
terrytao.wordpress.com
terrytao.wordpress.com
/math major
What you cannot do is put specific points on it, say three equidistant ones, or two at a distance of PI. If you allowed such constructs, the 'game' would become extraordinarily dull.
If you were allowed to mark the straightedge then you could put 2 random marks on it. With 2 random marks, you can trisect any angle. The location of the marks doesn't matter, just their existence.
It also, to me, isn't evident to me how one can proof that that Neusis construction is possible to place the ruler in that way without resorting to analytical means. I guess somebody must have thought about that. Are you aware of more rigid geometric proofs?
Very interesting as it might be for lovers of flat paper, I wonder if this is true of all topologies. I'd guess not but I'm not mathematician.
So can you trisect an angle in this slightly exotic topology? There's a good chance that you can, actually. There's a construction in the plane for trisecting a segment. If that construction is still valid on the sphere, you can take your angle and re-construct the legs with length equal to 1/4 of the sphere's circumference. Now, the line segment connecting the endpoints of these legs is an arc of a circle whose center is your angle. Trisecting this segment, and connecting the trisection back to the angle, will trisect the angle.
Reminded me of those p-adic sets where given the |a-b| metric:
- a circle radius is equal to its diameter
- all points inside the circle are a centre of that circle
- all triangles are isosceles
- appending a segment to itself may actually make it shorter
Actually, there are a lot of geometrical constructions that are possible with a finite number of operations with just a straightedge (not a ruler) and compass. Exactly bisecting an angle is easy. Trisecting is impossible.
construct an equilateral triangle atop the angle to be trisected bisect any side, construct a new triangle with said 30deg angle giving a line segment 1/sqrt(3) of the original eq tri bisect the new 60deg angle, constructing a new 30/60/90 tri
voila, 1/[sqrt(3)sqrt(3)] == 1/3. You have trisected a line with a compass and unmarked straightedge
Your arc intersections with |PQ| and |RQ| (call them p & q) give you an isosceles triangle pQr.
Construct an equilateral triangle on |pr| similar to: http://www.mathopenref.com/constequilateral.html