Easiest way to lose a locker room is having a manager/director who is technically inept.
Easiest way to lose a locker room is having a manager/director who is technically inept.
I think a better way to look at a manager is to compare it to the HR department.
Managers aren't hired by the people they will be managing, they're hired by the company.
In the same way that HR always represents the company's interests more than the employees, a manager is the exact same thing.
It's not in the interest of most company executives to hire a manager with the backbone to say "no" to management, or be on the side of the team being managed.
I think it's very rare when a manager is hired to actually manage properly. Most companies seem to value the very qualities that most people hate about bad managers.
Yet they are good coaches. Managers !== Coaches but I think you understand what I'm saying. Yes there are managers who are so technically incompetent that they are not good managers but most technical managers last management skills rather than technical skills and in most cases the technicals are not as important as the management skills. Any CTO/VP/Director of a mid/large sized company is a good example of this. They are no longer hands on. Their effectiveness comes from their ability to manage others.
>Easiest way to lose a locker room is having a manager/director who is technically inept.
For example, there are plenty of excellent soccer coaches that have never played soccer.
This type of thread shows up every couple of months here, and people use their anecdotal experience to define a whole role (which is different within itself and between organizations), which just feeds prejudice about a particular type of people, non-dev managers.
When in reality you have great managers from both technical and non-technical background.