“Send the money back or we’ll follow the laws we were supposed to be following anyway!”
Patio11 had a thread on Twitter better than this article.
Except that recent events regarding Citigroups incorrect $900M payout on the Revlon bond shows that in fact grown up finance will sometimes say, actually, the law is the law and the contract doesn't cover this, so thanks for the money.
This was a case where the bond holders did have some claim to the money, but it was clearly an error.
You refer to recent events, and I don't know how recent, so maybe I missed something; but my understanding was that the finding was that it was reasonable for Revlon to believe when they received the fund that it was a legitimate payment, not just an error. Of course in retrospect (e.g., when Citigroup calls and says so!) it is clear that it was an error, but the legal argument, whether or not you buy its truth, was that it was not clear at the time. I think that this sort of finding in which both grown-up financiers decide not to be chummy about misplaced funds, and the law sides with them in not requiring them to do so, is comparatively rare.
At most, it works like that for anyone rich or working on behalf of a big firm, which isn't exactly a ringing endorsement. And don't you worry, cryptocurrencies are just as capable of reversing transactions of those with the real power! [2]
[1] Thanks to blfr for finding the link: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1443738002065268736
[2] https://www.gemini.com/cryptopedia/the-dao-hack-makerdao
There are also a lot more ways for regular people to reverse transactions, but I take your point about how hard it is to reverse wires to scammers.
I'm still pretty bullish on DeFi.
Wash. Rev. Code §§ 9A.56.110, 9A.56.130, 9A.04.110
For example
Indeed, this is the key to make it "not blackmail".
That would seem to present all sorts of risks for his users, and himself, legal and otherwise.
(Also, I assume you mean tax evasion? Avoidance is the legal one.)
It does nothing of the sort. It's a enormous leap based on an assumption of bad faith to go from expecting protocol users to sort out their own personal tax situation to "willfully assisting in tax avoidance."
There are obviously lots of subtleties here, including places where no-one knows how the legal implications will shake out, but "expecting … users to sort out their own personal tax situation" isn't always an option; for example, my bank isn't allowed to assume I'll sort out my own personal tax situation and must report my interest earned, whereas, say, Amazon is allowed to make that assumption, and so need not report the items that they have sold to me. It could be that this is a more Amazon-y situation, but it could also be that it's a more traditional-bank-y situation. Probably even the IRS and Leshner, but definitely those of us who aren't involved in the situation, don't know which it is.
Precisely, which is why the jump to "strongly implies willfully assisting in tax avoidance" comes off so poorly. In my opinion, it not only mischaracterizes what is happening, it imputes ill intent to boot. Guidance for DeFi apps is poor currently and policy in this area is actively being legislated. In the meantime, shifting the onus for tax reporting back onto individual users !== willful assistance in tax avoidance any more than companies not witholding income taxes from payroll pre-WW2 was willful assistance in tax avoidance.
Further, since these transactions are all captured on a public ledger, anyone using this for tax avoidance is really just electing to pay their taxes later with massive penalties and possible jail time once the IRS gets around to tying addresses with unreported transactions to fiat on/off ramp transactions that are KYC'd.