Ozy Media Says It Is Shutting Down
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
I did work for a VC myself, and it got ripped off by a founder who had already a criminal record for fraud, was on parole, and was not even allowed to be the CEO of a company...
They gave him over $10 million, and it was more than obvious that his website was fishy, but they were completely fascinated by how much his crappy website was already making...
Edit: this was the state of my knowledge back in 2017, I've googled what happened since. He had to step down from his functions, was convicted to pay a fine for running a company despite having being bared to do so. There is also a civil suit against him that has not been settled yet it seems. It does not look like that he was charged with fraud or anything else than running a company despite being bared to do so. It appears that he has started a new business in the Crypto space now. Note that this story happened in Germany and you don't go to jail easily here.
His former startup went bankrupt but was acquired out of bankruptcy and found a new owner. He reduced the employee count from 100 to 20, scrapped all expansion plans to refocus on its core market and was able to make the company profitable in 2019.
Maybe no skin in the game skin they’re just investing LP money? Strange either way.
That's convenient for the government.
The way the system here in Switzerland works is thus:
The government has an office which supplies a certificate that says "this person has not had criminal charges pressed against them for the crimes X, Y and Z for the last N years".
A bank can demand (and did, in my case) this certificate from new employees for crimes like Fraud and violent crimes (I assume).
The job candidate requests the certificate from the government and hands a copy over to the company. Obviously if they know they would fail, they don't have to do this part, and can simply stop pursuing the job instead.
IIRC (this wasn't relevant for me), a company weren't allowed to simply ask for a wildcard certificate, it had to be reasonable for the job.
For a VC, missing out on a "unicorn of unicorns" investment can have dire consequences. IIRC at one point YC said that the vast majority of their value was from just AirBnB, Dropbox and Stripe (may have changed since I remember reading this).
But VCs exist in companies that fail all the time for a myriad of reasons. So putting in 10 million in a company that turns out to be a scam is probably not that big of a deal for most sizable VCs.
With that level of asymmetry it's not surprising that FOMO is the driving force here.
It also depends on getting accurate information in the first place and a private company can hide a lot.
There’s also the condition that VCs might have found out and passed but won’t really make much noise about it. They usually don’t have much to gain in calling out “bad” deals and can even hurt them in the future so they stay quiet, for better or worse.
Similar to how Elizabeth Holmes had money thrown at her for being a #girlboss, Ozy's CEO and COO were both "people of color". It's that last point that's been bandied about in social media a lot over the past few days, claims that the NYT is attacking a business because it's led by people of color.
For instance the Ford Foundation, one of the company's investors, said: "in an increasingly diverse world, it's no wonder a company founded by people of color is so successful." This was after the NYT article. (source: https://youtu.be/1pE9yqE5yMk?t=314). These investors just wanted to increase the number of companies they're invested in that are from people of color, even if the business fundamentals aren't legitimate.
This is more likely that individuals read about how to play around with metrics because they couldn't believe that other companies were doing so, and they tried it themselves, and to their surprise VCs came out of the woodwork and didn't gatekeep by race at all. This is much more similar to Blazing Saddles when the frontier town was perplexed that the new Mayor was black and the Mayor realized how dumb they all truly were and played with their emotions with a funny ruse.
The craziest story (which sounds a bit like your guy) I encountered was that of Shaun MacDonald [1], founder of two crypto companies called BCT and CG Blockchain. A company I worked for signed a business deal with BTC before they went under in 2019.
MacDonald was later revealed to be a convicted Canadian white-collar criminal with the unlikely name of Boaz Manor, who had stolen millions of dollars from hedge funds and who appears to have absconded with millions worth in diamonds [2] (!).
BCT/CG Blockchain turned out to be a scam, too. [3]
[1] https://torontolife.com/city/boaz-manor-toronto-crypto-fraud...
[2] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/rob-magaz...
[3] https://protos.com/boaz-manor-blockchain-terminal-sec-lawsui...
It took 5 days from publishing to a complete company shutdown.
And it's an entirely separate thing for the CEO to defend said fraud as a mental health oopsie, and then the chairman of the Board to defend the CEO for running a forgiving ship.
Clown car, front to back. Every one of the people involved should be investigated, in their activities pertaining to Ozy Media as well as everything else they're supposedly involved with and/or overseeing.
In April 2020 the total raised amount grew to $83M.
The company supposedly made $50M of revenue in 2020 and claimed to be profitable.
So from here, why did they try to raise more? Probably because the revenues and profit were not real.
In February 2021 the company tried to defraud Goldman Sachs of $40M.
I've read from another source that OZY was able to raise even more money 2 months after having failed to defraud Goldman Sachs. The total amount of money raised could thus be in the 100 millions.
You can't bounce back from something like that.
[0] https://edition.cnn.com/2021/09/30/media/ozy-work-culture/in...
"18-hour days and panic attacks: Former Ozy staffers allege an abusive environment" - https://edition.cnn.com/2021/09/30/media/ozy-work-culture/in...
"How troubled media firm Ozy was 'saved' from Fyre Festival-style exposure in 2019 after heat wave canceled Central Park event" - https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10043157/Ozy-saved-...
"Ozy Built a TV Show on a False Claim, Says Its Former Producer " - https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/30/business/media/ozy-media-...
Some possibilities: Some people like to join the angry mob and pile on, stories become more interesting to the news publishers (e.g., what was yet another story about an abusive culture at some unknown company becomes much more interesting now that people care about Ozy), and people who might have hesitated previously now feel safe sharing their stories, now that Ozy is down and impotent.
It's an important question; the phenomenon, IME, has nothing to do with the validity of the target; it happens to good people too.
All of the sudden OZY employees and former OZY employees get bombarded with messages from journalists on Linkedin, Twitter and Facebook.
That's when people start to talk, and the story gets even bigger.
Carlos Watson set himself out as a very powerful person who interviewed lots of famous and powerful people, had powerful investors, and had hoodwinked a lot of credible institutions (he was supposed to host the News & Documentary Emmys THIS week), it’s completely reasonable for people who work at a place like this to fear reprisal in finding other jobs, and thus choose to stay silent. In fact, staying quiet in a lot of these cases is the most rational choice. The people at Goldman Sachs and the VCs had little reason to speak out, easier to just quietly cut ties rather than face questions about why you backed a scammer to begin with.
It often takes someone who can’t be hurt by the person in power (or can’t be hurt as much), usually backed by an institution that is more/equally powerful as the subject, to break the proverbial dam. In this case, it was Ben Smith and The New York Times. Whatever anyone thinks of The Times, its reputation and stature as an institution is nearly unmatched (The New Yorker and The Wall Street Journal have similar reputations), it employs rigorous fact checkers for this kind of story, and the columnist in this story, has an excellent reputation and his own Rolodex of powerful sources and allies. As soon as he tore the lid off, it was safe for others to come forward.
One former employee went from an anonymous source to Fortune to on-the-record with CNN in less than 24 hours. My own experience tells me that the source was willing to go on the record with CNN after it became clear that Ozy/Watson/Rao was no longer in a position to harm her.
Look at Theranos. The Wall Street Journal was one of the only institutions in the world that could break that story. John Carreyrou had the backing of his editors, but Theranos tried to stop publication, first through thinly veiled threats by their legal counsel (led by the incredibly powerful David Boies) and going as far for Elizabeth Holmes to try to intervene with the owner of Journal (and Theranos investor) Rupert Murdoch. No smaller outlet or whistleblower could have done if. In fact, one of Carreyrou's sources, Tyler Schulz, was threatened by lawyers, his parents nearly bankrupt in legal bills, and cast-out by his grandfather (Theranos board member George Schulz). Imagine if Tyler's parents hadn’t had $500,000 to spend on legal bills or if he hadn’t talked to someone at The Wall Street Journal, does anyone think that story would have come out?
NBC News rejected Ronan Farrow's reporting on Harvey Weinstein, even though Farrow is famous and well-connected, leading him to take his reporting to The New Yorker. The Times was independently pursuing the story too, and the two outlets shared the Pulitzer, but the fact that NBC News turned down a story from a reporter they paid lots of money (and who at one time had a show on one of their networks), shows just how difficult it is to sometimes speak truth to power.
> It's an important question; the phenomenon, IME, has nothing to do with the validity of the target; it happens to good people too.
This can be true, but I think it is less true than you imply. Yes, everyone can enjoy a good pile-on, for good people or bad. But typically when these sort of under-the-radar stories break through, the reason all the stories come out at once is that people were afraid of being unhireable by speaking out against someone in power.
Because Weinstein was threatening to take Matt Lauer down with him if they broke the story.
Ozy was launched as a digital magazine and daily newsletter in September 2013. The company raised a $5.3 million seed round of funding in December 2013 backed by Laurene Powell Jobs, founder of Emerson Collective. Additional early investors include Louise Rogers and Ron Conway.
In October 2014, Ozy announced that German media giant Axel Springer had invested $20 million in the company. In January 2017, Ozy announced a $10 million Series B round of fundraising, led by Michael Moe's GSV Capital. In November 2019 Ozy announced a Series C round of $35 million, led by businessman Marc Lasry.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OZY_(media_company)
I'll note that it didn't even rate mention on HN until the past week as well.
Nightmare fuel.
Ozy != Ozzy
IMO, it always reads decently, but I never know what is missing and what parts are accurate.
Wikipedia has gatekeepers and wikilawyers that keep highly contested/popular and even some niche pages from being altered even with sources. Many have been through it, it happened to me.
For the purposes of identifying the basic outlines of the ex-parrot^Wcompany, the passage I've quoted is helpful in esablishing when the firm began operations, etc. Again, I had no information going in.
The meta-discussion of Wikipedia's accurac without identifying specific issues does little for any readers of this thread. It didn't with the first comment on that topic, and it continues to be the case. I'm done.
You seemed to take all of this as an attack against you personally, I assure you it was not, please calm down.
No one said there was a better source, only that Wikipedia is far from perfect.
No specifics need be given Wikipedia when its a truism that Wikipedia can be edited by anyone.
Nevertheless here[1] is a page from Wikipedia about the reliability of Wikipedia.
And since you are asking for specifics as if none exist, here[2] is an HN thread about issues with Wikipedia in which many examples and specifics are given.
Now I, too, am done.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_is_not_a....
And look at the Internet - mis/disinfo is having a field day.
* You need to spend time: First you must find the source; what is provided in Wikipedia often is a dead link, or a book, or something else inaccessible. Then you have to read it; it can take time to find the spot in the entire source that supports the statement. It might require analysis and interpretation (I've often seen claims that relied on shoddy interpretation of evidence), including of the context and the quality of the source. And finally, if the source doesn't support the claim (which I've seen many times) it takes even longer - proving a negative, that the evidence doesn't exist, requires reading the entire source with some care.
* Citations and references don't tell you when important information is omitted. For example, I could write that President X promised reform, in detail, and provide citations; I could easily omit that X had promised reform every year for five years and never delivered. I could write that Adam punched Bob and cite it, and omit that Bob punched Adam first. Another way of saying it: Accuracy is defined in some domains as Correct, Complete, and Consistent. Wikipedia is often (not always) Correct in what it says, but not Complete or Consistent.
Really looking forward to the Ozy documentary.
I really hope we're starting to see the end of the "fake it till you make it" era.
Makes one suspect they read the tweet about the poem, and not the poem itself.
Beware of charismatic CEOs spinning big tales.
What I don't understand is why you wouldn't also purchase a propotional number of "likes" to at least make the data look convincing to an unassuming third party.
100k+ views, 7 likes. A 10-year old could tell you this data looks fraudulent.
But a serious issue for the public is whether a culture exists that normalizes this behavior. Someone here said Ozy didn't realize they crossed a line, but did they actually cross a line, by the norms of that culture? Their board defended them. If the story hadn't reached the ears of a NYT journalist, wouldn't Ozy's investors, board, business partners all have accepted it? Fraud is economically very inefficient (resources aren't directed to the most efficient use, but to the most deceitful - not a recipe for economic growth), and breeds other criminality.
Finally, didn't YouTube cut them off after that? Wouldn't that have been a major blow to their business? Maybe that's why Goldman Sachs pulled out.
anyway, we're talking 1/100 the size of theranos, so could be worse