Cropping is never the right choice for media presentation. Ever.
When I was a kid in the 90's I remember that it was not uncommon to have black-and-white movie recolored to make them look more contemporary. This is arguably an even bigger betrayal of the original artistic vision and I expect done for very much the same reasons.
There is no good argument. Cropping out huge amounts of the actual material is not justifiable. End of story.
It's still good.