In the end, though? Yeah, I was completely wrong. I don’t know much about graphics engineering and I’m glad(^) that we were shown up by somebody who does.
I’ve been working in software for nearly 20 years, and I’m firmly in the “knows enough to be dangerous; doesn’t know everything” category the article is missing. It’s not, as some have characterized in this comment section, because I moved into leadership; rather, it is because there is not a single axis on which to measure all engineers. I’m inexperienced in graphics and text layout, and my critical mistake was not respecting the experience somebody else brought to the table. In other fields, perhaps I fall higher on the experienced/wet-behind-the-ears scale.
(^) I may flatly disagree with his presentation and his group of fans taking every opportunity to slander us, but I’m happy that it’s generally possible for us to improve performance and engineering efficiency using the technique he described. :)
Conversely, I think I went overboard defending you and your team, to the point of making my own over-broad generalization about game devs in another subthread [1]. I'm glad it's practical to get the best of both worlds in this case.
It's hard to clearly communicate on the internet "we could do better here, we'd love some help, but you don't need to be an asshole about it". Once casey was set on his warpath, I think it was just too late.
Just remember that there’s a huge number of people who appreciate the work you’re doing to modernize terminal experiences on Windows (nearly 78k GitHub stars!)
One guy is not 100% correct one day (because we overworked devs always are?), and the next day someone has written a blog text painting him as a subpar dev and now he is on front page of HN used as an example...