No, your antibodies are not better than vaccination
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
Okay. Let's be clear on something.
Telling the truth is never a downside.
It is not a negative that the U.S. doesn't pretend that immunity due to prior infection is due to the vaccine. Suggesting that these cases should be counted in favor of vaccine efficacy is brazenly dishonest.
This article is flamebait.
This seems to be a complete misreading of what the article is saying. Nowhere does it claim that "immunity due to prior infection should be counted as due to the vaccine" merely that it makes the "unvaccinated" group look better than it actually is, as it should be further subdivided to "account for past infection" in a subgroup.
Drawing the conclusion that we should therefore ignore the article entirely is unwarranted. Let us not be brazenly dishonest.
2. If you are going to go this far, you'd also want the "vaccinated but had no effect" group.
The vaccine will not generate an immune response (or an effective one) in everyone, that's just how it works.
So the vaccinated group (and "breakthrough cases") include some percent of people who were vaccinated, but it didn't really do anything to them.
You'd want to know this number, because you want to know things like "how many breakthrough cases are people where the vaccine had no real effect vs people where the vaccine generated an effective antibody response, but not against this variant"
Especially because the "breakthrough" rate is small.
> This waters down case rates in the unvaccinated group and ends up lowering the vaccine efficacy estimates.
the implication is that she'd prefer for three groups to be tracked:
1. never infected, never vaccinated
2. previously infected but not vaccinated
3. vaccinated.
The idea isn't to lump 2 and 3 together, but merely to stop lumping 1 and 2 together. Fair enough.
The 5 groups:
1a. Never vaccinated, No prior infection
1b. Never vaccinated, prior infection
2a. Vaccinated, No prior infection
2b. Vaccinated, prior infection (Infected then Vaccinated)
2c. Vaccinated, prior infection (Vaccinated then Infected)
I'll use some BS numbers to make the point. Let's assume: study population of 100, 20% of the population had a prior infection, half are given the snake oil.
Starting conditions:
1. Never infected, Never Snaked: 40
2. Prior infected, Never Snaked:10
3. Never infected, Snaked: 40
4. Prior infected, Snaked: 10
Now let's assume wave 2 happens. 20% of the never infected gets infected, and 0% of the previously infected get reinfected.
Both groups 1+2 combined and 3+4 combined have an average infection rate of 16% for wave 2. The groups are equal because snake oil is bullshit.
What the Ars author was suggesting is to compare group 1 with group 3+4 combined. Now you have a 20% infection rate vs a 16% infection rate. The snake oil appears to have an (20-16)/20 = 25% effectiveness just by including previously acquired immunity.
At a baseline, naturally generated antibodies/t-cell response almost always targets more than just the spike protein (ie nucleoprotein regions, etc). These often make them effective against a lot more variants, as those regions are much more preserved than the spike protein. Duplicating this response is the whole goal of the 2nd generation vaccine programs NIAID and others are running - to generate the same kind of response as a backstop against variants (it has a secondary goal of needing less dosage to vaccinate people). We are trying to better mimic the response the human body gives naturally.
Natural response also lasts a long time (in effectiveness), too: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2550-z
"Next, we showed that patients (n = 23) who recovered from SARS (the disease associated with SARS-CoV infection) possess long-lasting memory T cells that are reactive to the N protein of SARS-CoV 17 years after the outbreak of SARS in 2003".
17 years.
(Additionally, to the earlier point, lots of people infected with earlier SARS-COV variants appear to have an effective immune response to SARS-COV-2, because the natural generated response targeted preserved-between-viruses regions)
Now, this doesn't mean that you shouldn't get vaccinated if you were infected - in fact, the strongest immunity that is seen from people who were infected and then vaccinated. This appears to generate a very strong, very effective response.
But this "hunting with a shotgun instead of a sniper rifle" stuff is just stupid. So is citing 2 studies that say different things and saying "therefore i've proven natural immunity is unreliable"
Any real discussion about vaccination vs natural immunity would have to go into CD4/CD8 response, what regions are targeted/preserved in mutations, etc.
IMHO These kinds of articles do a lot more harm than good, because the misinfo in them is easy to discover, and that convinces people even further of conspiracies. They take an area where science is actually trying to figure out the answers (we aren't all that good at understanding the immune response), and pretends we know. That isn't going to help get people vaccinated.
> Now, this doesn't mean that you shouldn't get vaccinated if you were infected - in fact, the strongest immunity that is seen from people who were infected and then vaccinated. This appears to generate a very strong, very effective response.
How does this relate to "Original Antigenic Sin", aka the Hoskins effect?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_antigenic_sin
It must be that this effect isn't that strong, or else the subsequent vaccination wouldn't do anything? Or is it precisely because the vaccine doesn't have any of the other markers, that the immune system is now forced to learn a new, second response?