Ask HN: Would HN be better without votes and with tagged streams?
Google... check! Software patents... check! Lodsys... check!
These seem to topics of interest to the HN crowd and very timely news. We're not talking "The history of yarn and knitting patterns" here.
Did it just go unnoticed or is there gaming at play here to promote the submissions of a select few?
I honestly don't know. My own submissions, which I thought would be inline with the average HN reader's interests, have suffered a similar fate and I took it upon myself to research getting on the HN front page.
The advice is bleak... 1. Be a super-important person. 2. Be part of a Digg-like clique which trades up-votes. 3. Make your own fake users and up-vote yourself.
I'm not super important and I don't want to lower myself by cheating. Instead I want to propose another option...
SCRAP THE VOTING SYSTEM ALTOGETHER!
Instead offer... 1. A giant fire hose with all the submissions for those who can handle it. 2. Tag-based streams where submissions can assign up to 3 tags to describe their content. (ex: "patents", "google", "lodsys")
HN readers can specify tags they're interested in (as many as they like in fact) as well as tags they are not interested in. This filters the fire hose! They see news they want to see and avoid the news that doesn't interest them and there is no incentive to game the system. They can turn off the filter and explore new topics if they wish too!
I PUT THESE QUESTIONS TO YOU...
Have you had your contributions to HN languish in obscurity when the next person posts something similar only to be launched to the front page within minutes? What do you think of these ideas?