On “natural immunity” to Covid-19 (and every other vaccine-preventable disease)
respectfulinsolence.com
respectfulinsolence.com
Well, actually, it is. People are often arguing they don't need a vaccine because they already had COVID, not advocating for people to get COVID instead of the vaccine.
When you have to falsely charecterize your opponents in order to crow about how stupid they are you're not likely to change any minds.
But go ahead, make it "Science Believers" vs "stupid Rednecks". That's been the trend for a while; and when vaccines are no longer the hobby horse to ride there will be another.
The point of trite like this isn’t to change any minds, everybody knows you can’t do that by preaching to the choir. The point is to make yourself seem better, smarter, holier than the others. And what better way to do that than by diminishing the other? As a bonus you will make all your readers think they are better than the others as well and who doesn’t want that?
It might not change minds, but that doesn't mean it doesn't instill an initial position. And it definitely prevents many people from even considering an alternative position.
Look at the ivermectin controversy. It's an FDA approved medicine, listed as one of the most necessary in the world which has a Nobel prize for it's discovery.
But how many (even educated) people won't take the time to even realize that, because it's been branded nothing more than "horse de-wormer" taken by gullible idiots who buy it from the feed & seed store?
And you end up in a position where you can't even debate efficacy or ethical/philosophical questions re: policy and medical self-determination, but get stuck because the "more enlightened" side doesn't even realize it's real medicine, FDA approved and tested as safe, used all around the world regularly by human patients.
This is oversimplifying. A medicine is effective or not for particular conditions, not in general. FDA approval of drugs like this is "safe and effective" _for_ a particular use, not general "approval" for every purpose.
As for safe, "the dose makes the poison". (1)
The correct dose of Ivermectin is of course useful for control of parasites in humans and other animals such as horses, but it is not useful for COVID-19 (4).
However people have in fact "bought Ivermectin from the feed store" (2) and self-dosed with the wrong amount, effectively poisoning themselves (3) for nothing (4). You can call this "gullible idiots" if you like, but it's sad that they were mislead on something so consequential.
If Ivermectin was effective for COVID-19, then medical staff would be administering safe doses.
Fortunately there are are drugs arriving that have demonstrated effectiveness against COVID-19 (5), there is no need to cling to Ivermectin
1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dose_makes_the_poison
2) https://www.iflscience.com/health-and-medicine/store-only-le...
3) https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2021/0...
4) https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-58170809
5) https://edition.cnn.com/2021/10/11/health/molnupiravir-covid...
https://www.ft.com/content/17cf953b-38b5-4862-814f-ad51f1066...
> If Ivermectin was effective for COVID-19, then medical staff would be administering safe doses.
They are doing that, you just don't hear about it for the reasons stated above.
> Fortunately there are are drugs arriving that have demonstrated effectiveness against COVID-19 (5), there is no need to cling to Ivermectin
If you just read the details of those new drugs, you can see it's mostly Ivermectin.
Admittedly I have no sources, but again, if you don't believe me, I would just say consider expanding your sources of information, what I'm saying isn't hard to find.
I am not here for this conspiracy-theorising rabbit hole
> They are doing that (medical staff would be administering safe doses of Ivermectin for COVID-19)
Citation needed, and study results needed.
> the details of those new drugs, you can see it's mostly Ivermectin.
I am a loss to pinpoint the misunderstanding that gives rise to statements like this. In what way are different chemicals "mostly Ivermectin" and how did you arrive at that belief?
FYI, if you want to dig deeper, the relevant Wikipedia pages are https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molnupiravir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivermectin
And I'm not seeing a similarity of structure or mechanism, are you? The other drug, AstraZeneca's AZD7442, "contains two different antibodies" so won't be anything like _either_ of these.
> consider expanding your sources of information
Thank you for the suggestion, I have seen it before but I have never seen it mean anything other than "you should read the same junk science and disinformation as I, to validate my choices" and then fail to give examples that are both specific and reputable.
It's not a rabbit hole, but it is a different thread. I can summarize it this way: official media outlets can only give you a partial picture. It's not in their best interest to show you the full picture for multiple reasons. Any meta-analysis would reveal this, but those results would, of course, never show up in those sources.
> And I'm not seeing a similarity of structure or mechanism, are you? The other drug, AstraZeneca's AZD7442, "contains two different antibodies" so won't be anything like _either_ of these.
I can't comment on the specific chemical properties or differences in the molecules. I also cannot fully expand on everything that I've read and watched on this, or give sources, sorry. There is really too much information. However, you can see ivermectin has anti-viral properties in the wiki, and the Covid19 section just says it's not approved with exception fo the trials. It's not far-fetched to suggest the official authorities on this will end up concluding it does help. Additionally, it has been tried around the world, this isn't another "theory". Again, it's just not reported by the main outlets.
> "you should read the same junk science and disinformation as I, to validate my choices"
Not really what I'm saying. We are transitioning worlds right now. The old world consisted of a concentrated number of official media outlets telling people what was the truth. The new world consists of anyone having the ability to search for multiple angles of what the truth could be. It is certainly harder and more time-consuming to the work, but that doesn't mean there aren't thousands of perfectly capable people doing the work and sharing it to the world to the demise of these official outlets, which seem to be desperately trying to stay as the only source of information by demonizing everything else.
The first is that specialised subjects are not well-understood by everyone else. Your frankly incoherent and "not even wrong" statements regarding Ivermectin vs other drugs are a good example of this. You assert confidently; but when pressed, you admit not understanding the necessary context at all.
The second is that if the mainstream media has a problem with being complete and unbiased, then this goes more than double for other sources. Misunderstanding and disinformation is rife. Easy (wrong but satisfying) answers are easy to come by. And people seeking fame are eager to supply them.
As they used to say in computing: "Garbage in, Garbage out" We run the risk of being garbage repeaters.
The media is changing, that is inevitable. However there is no guarantee that the change will be an improvement. From what we have seen so far, it is not.
I'm not surprised that you did not give any examples of your sources, this is the pattern, nothing that can be held up to scrutiny. We may be "We are transitioning worlds right now" but that does not mean that chemical facts will go away via wishful thinking. Delusions about such consequential matters will continue to to have consequences.
But, now their choice isn't good enough?
There are people who claim that they are not afraid of the virus but refuse to get vaccinated.
There is also mixing up of natural immunity and innate immunity. Many people claim that they do not need the vaccine because they have innate immunity (they usually using simply "immune system").
Unfortunately US does not recognize acquired immunity by being ill.
It would be better to use different wording altogether: "vaccinated", "recovered".