“There are endless Twitter bots which do exactly the same thing; scrape all the HN links and cross-post them to Twitter”
Here’s a single account example I found… and I’ve seen more like it before.
https://twitter.com/park_junbeom/status/1447511436666675203
You’ll notice that, that account also has numerous random links to products, probably farming traffic to those as well. In the ad business this is a strategy to foster network effect traffic signals.
And then there’s karma. I don’t have direct evidence because I don’t have the time to investigate, but this quote rings true to me, and I’m sure other here:
“hacker news is a nexus of karma farming bot activity”
Here’s an example of what I’m referring too. In this case it’s not a bot, but a human run vote system:
https://www.appsally.com/products/hacker-news-karma/
I’ve been in the advertising space for a long time. It’s very hard to combat this type of stuff. There are basically sweat shops in places like India devoted to these things, and it took google years to rid its ad system of it, and they threw enormous money and AI at the problem.
So when you say with 100% certainty it’s not happening, but you have many serious users complaining, it feels like an issue.
I truly think that social media companies are not really aware of the depth of what they are fighting. Here’s a report from Oxford university:
https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2021-01-13-social-media-manipulati...