Ask HN: Why Microsoft reinvents Help file formats many times?
Finally their updated product (like Explorer) just open website or even Bing search result.
Finally their updated product (like Explorer) just open website or even Bing search result.
The third has special features for CLI programs, and is much more recent, so I can see why they didn’t want to build on earlier work.
The fourth is the modern way. It makes fixing help easier (no updates to send out), and effectively doesn’t have space restrictions.
As to .hlp, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WinHelp#End_of_support says
“Ted Dworkin (Partner Director of WinHelp Experience) stated, "WinHelp does not meet the code standards established for Vista. These standards include security, reliability, and performance." He went on to say that WinHelp is designed in such a way that, "...we would have to rewrite it from the ground up to meet the Vista code standards. And that approach doesn't make sense given that we have two other Help systems in Vista”.