To be fair, we're talking about New York State. Which is the center of finance in the US. The regulators in NY-State have an outsized influence on this sort of thing.
To be fair, we're talking about New York State. Which is the center of finance in the US. The regulators in NY-State have an outsized influence on this sort of thing.
It will be a good day indeed, to see NY Fall from that status.
> New York’s Martin Act sets forth a broad list of instruments that are declared to be securities and thus subject to its provisions: “any stocks, bonds, notes, evidences of interest or indebtedness or other securities…or negotiable documents of title, or foreign currency orders, calls or options therefor hereinafter called security or securities.” As courts have stated for almost a century, the Martin Act is a remedial statute, intended to protect the investing public, which means that its provisions — including those setting forth the definition of a “security” — are to be given a broad reading. Indeed, those defined categories of instruments are not exhaustive; other instruments or arrangements can, and have been, deemed securities under the law
Note that this doesn't just impact lenders based in NY, it impacts anybody lending to New Yorkers.
The US in turn, is up there as one of the worst countries for cryptochoice up there with Cuba, Crimea and Sevastopol, Iran, Afghanistan, Syria, North Korea, or Antigua. (Granted the US is there because of 'legitimate' SEC regulations, but ther is no reason NY should be more restrictive than the feds).
[1] The ability of the indiviual to choose which crypto they want to buy and availability of them
[2] https://help.ftx.com/hc/en-us/articles/360042412652-Location...
Edit: Unless you meant all of the thinly traded altcoins they've been adding which, yes, NY State has been correct to forbid. Penny stock fraud but with tire burning as the economic substrate.
Most platforms choose the former, and even if a platform chooses option 2 it takes time, money etc etc. Now, even tough DOGE was widely traded in the entire US it was not allowed in NY at the beginning of last year. So what happened now, did it become a 'better' coin? No! Will SHIB be a 'better' coin magically once it's 'registered'? Of course not. Point is, however much you hate crypto there is no point to this restrictive law.
This misses the point: the financial legwork doesn't make any of these altcoins "better," it just makes their use more transparent to regulators. That transparency is in the public's interest. It's not the AG's job to make cryptocurrency better; it's her job to ensure that the laws of the State of New York are obeyed.
That is because of these burdensome "You-need-us-to-protect-you-because-you-are-not-smart-enough-to-make-educated-choices" crypto laws.
There are lots of different ways to ensure "scam" cryptos don't end up in NY. Being overly restrictive doesn't help NY'ers at all.